Reviewer: NobleLandMermaid Signed 1
Date: December 14, 2020
Title: Chapter 1: After the War
While I’m not one of those fans that thinks Jim’s pranks “terrorized” or even really bullied Dwight (the show needs humor, people!) the snowball always bothered me since it was such a line crossed (I’m honestly not really sure what the writers were doing with Jim in S7, he’s frequently quite out of character). Dwight dishing it back 100x harder was in line for Dwight but still, the whole thing was dark and mean-spirited.
All that said, this is a great fix-it for the iffy choices the show made in this ep. Pam calling Jim out on the snowball is something the actually episode would have benefited greatly from and you write a conversation I can easily imagine, and the voices are all great in the mediation session. The show kinda weirdly portrayed Holly as ineffective HR rep so it’s nice to have her here displaying that she’s quite good at her job. Great work, 3V!
Author's Response:
Many thanks!
Season 7 is one of the weaker ones for me, only redeeming itself with the well-executed conclusion Michael's story. (Also, Threat Level Midnight.) And yeah, the episode just made me squirm because, while it's certainly in-character for Dwight (and his guerrilla warfare tactics and lines are just that galaxy-brain), him not knowing when to stop like Jim does just leaves him traumatized. Like, Dwight deserves the occasional W, but not like this.
I appreciate the compliments on my additions! To me, Holly was never ineffective, per se, she was just in the show for so little that we had no idea how she operated like Toby did. She's kind, personable, respectable, and level-headed, all the qualities of a good HRR... *but* her goofing off with Michael was more fun to write, which I get. And yeah, Pam should have said something then and there... come to think of it, if she did, she probably would have talked Dwight out of it and there wouldn't be a B-plot.
As for the treatment of Jim in S7, to me it's only the middle of the season where he gets weird, especially with that third-grade friend of his showing up at the seminar. Literally why. I think they tried to do more of S6 where it delved into the character's shortcomings and have him learn from them... but the co-manager arc pretty much accomplished that. And while co-manager!Jim is my least favorite Jim, at least it was essential for his character development. I think they ran out of stuff for him to do before Phillip H. Pam's line in "New Guys" rings truer than one might think, it seems.
Thanks for the review!