Reviewer: StarryDreamer Signed
Date: March 08, 2007
Title: Chapter 5: Chapter 5
"It's not over." She murmured the words aloud, staring over at him, feeling almost surreal because for once - for once - she wasn't running away.
This part sent my heart right into my throat. I wondered if Jim had heard her say it. But I thought it was profound to have her say it out loud, as though she was finally accepting what she'd known all along.
He jumped when he felt someone touch him, lips pressing lightly against his own.
This part literally sent chills down my spine. Literally. So bold, so FNB. But I loved it.
In regards to whether there needs to be an epilogue... quite honestly I thought that the chapter ended sort of sad. Even though there was a promise of a future, and that the reader totally knows they would be together- the imagery of Pam watching Jim walk away to his car (when just hours earlier she'd asked him to stay out of sheer necessity) was painfully sad... even though it was a happy moment. And I did think that the line "We'll be back here soon; I promise" was very much foreshadowing a piggy-back scene.
And I loved your follow up to "Cocktails". I certainly needed it to get me through this insane 6 weeks. This story was just peppered with such romantic moments that were so beautifully written- if it were to be filmed I could imagine it with these lovely, soft, romantic hues. Congrats on another amazing job.
Author's Response: First of all, as soon as I saw your name, I got the biggest grin on my face. Seriously - in the seventeenth century, writers didn't rely so much on publishers as they did on patrons & circles of friends who circulated their work; so there was no money in it for the writers, just the thrill of having their work distributed. And I swear, I've come to think of you as my patron. :o)
Anyway.... I'm glad that moment resonated with you -- as you know from the author's note, the song of the same title inspired the fic, and when I wrote her saying those words out loud, it just sort of...came out. But on edit (and re-edit, and re-edit, etc.), I wasn't sure that it would come off as realistic - so I'm really happy to hear that it resonated with you. (And in response to whether or not Jim heard her - as I envisioned it, he was totally asleep and completely unaware. But I'm of the opinion that fiction is fluid, and more often than not, the reader can actually shape the story or have insights that totally escape the author - and yeah, I think the notion of Jim hearing her say that and rousing just a little would've been brilliant. Damn it. :oD)
I'm really so grateful for your thoughts on the ending - that you think it merits an epilogue because it's really sad. And you know, I see now that it is a sort of sad ending - maybe needs a follow through to the resolution. So yes, I'll definitely do an epilogue. (Because I'm not cruel like some people - looking at you Greg Daniels - and I'm committed to giving the people what they want. [/Jim])
Anyway, thanks so, so much for all your thoughtful, invaluable feedback (not to mention the continued support. It really does make such a difference.