Reviewer: LindsayLeigh Signed 10
Date: March 04, 2007
Title: Chapter 18: Chapter 18 - Seven Lines of Gossip
Oh my God. That email was soooo much better than anything that I might have been expecting. No wonder Pam was so shocked! No wonder she didn’t feel even a twinge of guilt about lying in her emails to the other office ladies. And no wonder she gave Phyllis the dare that she did. (Which I am still VERY upset with her for doing, just so you know, despite my understanding of her reasons.) AND no wonder Jim felt the need to hide it inside of an air vent! This is huge!!!
One of my (other) favorite parts of this chapter was the silent conversation held between Jim and Pam. So well written, and so expressive of how well they understand one another.
So apparently Jim noticed that email in his sent box, based on his comments to Phyllis and Angela last chapter. I think it’s only a matter of time before he realizes that the only person in the office that knows him well enough to guess his password is Pam, and then when he puts that together with the email she sent and the other things that have been going on, he might just start to piece things together a little bit. I’m excited to see where you go with this story line.
The conversation in the kitchen was very well written, too. You’re right, Mrs. Vance does know how to word things to keep everyone guessing. Poor Jim, getting all the way back to his seat before realizing he had no idea what the teensy lie was. I’m holding you to your word that you won’t break his heart. (A wee bit of stress may have returned concerning this point, just so you know.) And I loved how Kelly thought she was being all nonchalant and inconspicuous, when actually she had frozen in the middle of a page turn! Too funny. I can’t get over the way Kelly COMPLETELY misinterpreted EVERYTHING, however, and the way she said things, “Totally lied about everything in the email” and that Phyllis told Jim he should marry KAREN? Her email was too funny at the same time though--I loved when she said that Jim was probably not getting married for the same reasons as Brad Pitt, and the stuff about Oscar too, but still. I think I may finally understand Ryan Howard, and the way that one can love Kelly but still be completely furious with her. Seriously.
Also, please, please, please, don’t break Pam’s heart either, okay?
You may break Karen’s heart, if you feel it necessary.
Whew, sorry if that review was crazy long. Can you see what you’ve done to me with this story of your’s? It’s seriously out of control. (And still my favorite story ever.) You’re such a great writer, and you still make me laugh out loud with every chapter. Thanks so much for all the hard work you’ve put into it, and please do update soon! J
Author's Response: Well, rather than write the next chapter, I’m just going to respond to this review because it is simply A-MAZING! First of all, I think you should start your own MTT non-fic story that you can title “Just for Muggins to Read”. I’d like to hear your opinions on what you think is going on in each of The Office episodes because you NAILED my story! I just know you’ve got the inside scoop on the show itself!
No wonder Pam was so shocked! No wonder she didn’t feel even a twinge of guilt about lying in her emails to the other office ladies. And no wonder she gave Phyllis the dare that she did. AND no wonder Jim felt the need to hide it inside of an air vent! This is huge!!! Holy shmoly!!! Did you reread every frickin’ chapter? Sometimes I’ll have my boyfriend read a chapter before I post it and he’ll go “what’s that mean?” and I’ll say “that refers back to chapter 3 blah blah blah” and he says “oh. Maybe you should cut that. No one’s going to remember that.” Now I’ll show him your review and go HA HA HA HA! Niiiice!
One of my (other) favorite parts of this chapter was the silent conversation held between Jim and Pam. I had so much fun writing that part. I knew they couldn’t talk, not with Karen keeping such tabs on Jim. But I also knew I had to write some interaction before the whole Email thing truly blew up. So watch out, stormy waters ahead! Jim noticed that email in his sent box, YES. based on his comments to Phyllis and Angela last chapter EXACTLY. it’s only a matter of time before he realizes that it is Pam, YES puts that together with the email she sent YES and the other things that have been going on YES, he might just start to piece things together a little bit STORMY WATERS, BIG TUNA! Mrs. Vance does know how to word things to keep everyone guessing. BUT SHE’S GOTTEN IN OVER HER HEAD Poor Jim, getting all the way back to his seat before realizing he had no idea what the teensy lie was HE’S WORRYING ABOUT TOO MUCH RIGHT NOW AS IT IS…KAREN, SKETCHBOOK PICTURES, TEENSY LIE, DWIGHT & ANGELA DATING, COMPUTER BREAK IN, DELETED EMAILS, PAM’S EMBROIDERED PANTIES…POOR JIM, INDEED. I’m holding you to your word that you won’t break his heart CROSS MY HEART, NO HEARTBREAK FOR JIM. (A wee bit of stress may have returned concerning this point, just so you know.) NO STRESS. HAPPY THOUGHTS!!!
I can’t get over the way Kelly COMPLETELY misinterpreted EVERYTHING, however, and the way she said things, “Totally lied about everything in the email” and that Phyllis told Jim he should marry KAREN? I think I may finally understand Ryan Howard, and the way that one can love Kelly but still be completely furious with her. Seriously. I love Kelly with a love that can not be broken. When I was writing for her I was thinking of this game I played as a kid called “Telephone”. Kelly would be horrible at it. “She’s such a talker, but not a very good listener. So when she hears a word like “marry her” “teensy lie” etc. she stops listening and starts talking. In this case she had a very exciting internal monologue going. I never thought about Ryan Howard’s perspective! I don’t think I’ve ever written him talking, isn’t that weird? But that is some great insight! Another reason you have to write the “Just for Muggins to Read” non-fic. don’t break Pam’s heart either Not going to happen You may break Karen’s heart, if you feel it necessary. Also, not going to happen. No hearts broken! Now you can sleep easy.
Author's Response: Ugh! I typed this all in word and then cut and paste and it changed EVERYTHING to italics! I hope it doesn't make it to difficult to read