Reviewer: moofoot Signed 10
Date: November 22, 2006
Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1
Well if this isn't freaking perfect. Your Karen seems absolutely spot-on [especially for something you weren't comfortable doing?]; she's real and true and completely human, and this story makes me love her but still dislike Karen/Jim [not that that last bit was really necessary...] so this is definitely one of the best I've seen out there.
And I love your Karen, by the way. She's so painfully real. It's amazing how you got so much across which such little dialogue, like how she feels about him and what she thinks about herself, all of that. I would never see Karen as an overly sappy, drippy girl who chases after guys she may like and compromises herself for them, and I think even the guys she likes have to be special, and somehow you went a little against that as well as support that notion entirely, so that's brilliant. And I love that the thing that made Karen realise it was Pam Jim was in love with was how he held her hand, because
a) Karen's not daft, and
b) I love the idea of that, comparing the way he held their hands to figure that out.
I seriously cannot say how much I love this Karen. It's a darker take on her character in general; I really do think she has some sort of a background like that, although the writers will probably never explore that. As much as I want her out of the way, it kind of breaks my heart a little, and my heart doesn't break that easily. Really.
And how we got to see Jim and Pam become Jim/Pam through the eyes of Karen, as much as she wanted to ignore it, was great, too.
Also: the way you wrote this!! It's so Karen I feel unbelievably sad for this girl. The way she kept at guessing at the kind of girl Jim loved [and got it entirely wrong, which should say something about how much she's meant to be with him] and kind of changed herself, for him - I adored the way you finished off each section, how every time she becomes less and less like herself, she becomes less and less certain that she's the person who'd make him happy. The sentence you used, it's the kind of thing I'd do, except people don't get it that much or they don't point it out, and that makes me feel disappointed, so I figured I would point out that I noticed [!] and I absolutely love it.
She sits down at the table and pours her licorice pieces out onto a paper towel, lining them up like little corn syrup soldiers.
Hee!
There are so many other things that I loved about this story, but I'm stopping here in case others've mentioned it already; I'd just be repetitive and uhm...really long and rambley. But awesome stuff, seriously and genuinely. I would love to read more of your stuff.
Author's Response: Really, talk about an insightful reveiw...
I'm glad you could feel what I was going for. It's not always the case, but a lot of us do get caught up in a relationship or wanting to make ourselves feel more important to trump someone, or something. I think Karen is a strong, tough girl, but at the same time, she doubts herself (like when Jim told her to go to NY, and she said "ok" and then he told her she should go to Scranton, and again, she said "ok"... simply because she likes him).
I'm happy that you could see the little things in this fic, and that you thought it was good without dialogue - I can't write dialogue to save my life!
Thanks so much for taking the time to leave this review, moofoot.