Reviewer: Maxine Abbott Signed 1
Date: November 06, 2020
Title: Chapter 5: Dorky Dancing
So I've been meaning to get to this fic for a while now - there's so much to read being a newbie to the site plus everyone is posting like mad lately. Anyway I finally got to it and now I'm sorry I waited so long because now I'm way behind and I loved this first chapter and I anticipate they will all be a joy to read.
It might take me a while to get caught up since I want to really devote attention to the words because I think you have great insights and a great way of portraying the scene and I want to give my due attention.
ON to review
First off, the you/them stuff, the camps - yeah we've all been there thinking we were on the outside (at least I've been there at times), wanting to be on the inside. I love how you describe this.
And how Jim comes up, reads the situation and the Irish Cream banter very on point for them.
The dancing is great fun - I actually think they both dance pretty dorky - ever notice Jim dancing on show - he reminds me of the Peanuts characters when they show dancing scenes - even my son says the same thing. There's a scene in episode where they do the cold opening with the lip synch dance where it is so apparent. anyway I think the way they both dance is just one more reason they mesh so well.
Jim's lankiness description hits home because to me it does make him so endearing.
I love the way you tell the back story (could see it happening just like that ) and give both points of view that mirror each other in their conclusions.
The way you tie her comment about being blind to his feelings about it being easier if he were is perfect.
Coconut shampoo - seems to be the only scent available in Scranton - I've used it for Jim and I've seen it in so many other fics but LOVE it.
Really enjoyed this first chapter - Hope you enjoy my review - I know I love to hear about the things that resonate with readers. Can't promise I will always have the time to go on like this but I plan to read more.
Author's Response: Thank you so much for taking the time to write this review (I also love hearing about the things that resonated with readers, and I really enjoyed this one) - so it's hugely appreciated! And as another newbie, I am also struggling to keep up with all of the great fics on this site...
I can definitely relate to the us/them - I was also interested in writing about it from Pam's POV because I feel like Jim is naturally more confident and sociable than she is, but I don't think that's an issue when they're in the office (and it's not ever to him anyway).
I definitely agree that Jim is a dorky dancer! I was thinking specifically of his dancing in Cafe Disco when I was writing this. I love that episode mainly because of his dancing - I think it's the bouncing up and down on the spot for YMCA that does it.
And ha I'd not realised that about the coconut shampoo...I do also love it though.
Thank you again! :)