We closed out the 2010s with another fantastic year at the archive. We saw 125 new and updated stories in 2019 and with them many great quotes and swoonworthy moments. We asked our members to name a few of their favorites in several categories, as well as to show recognition to their fellow MTTers. So without further ado, The 2019 Dundies!
Favorite Overall Fanfics
- A Dollar Short by Comfect
- A Little Rough by MadiDavis
- An Education by Kuri333
- An Exercise in Courage and Honest by NobleLandMermaid
- Another White Dash by JennaBennett
- Begin Again by SprinklesTheCat
- Beyond the Horizon by agian18
- Christmas Visitors by Duchess Cupcake
- Cosa Nostra by Coley
- Drunk Me (Can't Get Over You) by agian18
- Engaged Ain't Married by Donnamour1969
- Gorgeous by SprinklesTheCat
- Groundhog Nights by Comfect
- Hello My Old Heart by Duchess Cupcake
- Here's a Hypothetical by Mel Like Mellow
- High Hopes by JennaBennett
- Holiday Rendezvous by NobleLandMermaid
- How Not To by agian18
- Journals of a Stay-at-Home-Dad by warrior4
- Kind of Reckless by Coley
- Living In Color by JennaBennett
- More (Than That) by celluloiddreams
- More Than a Day, More Than a Word by NobleLandMermaid
- Morning After by Comfect
- My Office Gave To Me by warrior4
- Nice Morning Too by MadiDavis
- Office Space by Comfect
- Perfect Mess by JennaBennett
- Restart by agian18
- Ruin the Friendship by Duchess Cupcake
- Safe and Sound by NobleLandMermaid
- Say Something (I'm Not Giving Up On You) by agian18
- Serendipity by Sam
- Skin and Chips by Kuri333
- Snaps by agian18
- Stilettos and Broken Bottles (Spinning Around in Circles) by Coley
- The Unflinchingly Rigid Rules of Jinx by Kuri333
- This Thing Called Life by warrior4
- This Year by JennaBennett
- Trick me, treat me by Coley
- Unwrapped by Coley
- Valentine's Fairy Godfather by Kuri333
- V-J Day by Comfect
- When Pam Met Jim by Donnamour1969
- Wishin' and Hopin' by Coley
- You Me and the Sea by JennaBennett
Favorite Longer Fics (10k+ Words)
- All Along it was a Fever by SprinklesTheCat
- Beyond the Horizon by agian18
- Cosa Nostra by Coley
- Crazy Night in Philly by misery crush
- Engaged Ain't Married by Donnamour1969
- Groundhog Nights by Comfect
- Hello My Old Heart by Duchess Cupcake
- Here's a Hypothetical by Mel Like Mellow
- How Not To by agian18
- Kind of Reckless by Coley
- Living in Color by Jenna Bennet
- More Than a Day, More Than a Word by NobleLandMermaid
- Notices by Comfect
- Office Space by Comfect
- Restart by agian18
- Ruin the Friendship by Duchess Cupcake
- Safe and Sound by NobleLandMermaid
- Serendipity by Sam
- Slow by agian18
- Stilettos and Broken Bottles by Coley
- The Romantic History of Jim Halpert by SprinklestheCat
- This Thing Called Life by warrior4
- Unwrapped by Coley
- Waiting in the Sun by WishYouWould
- When Pam Met Jim by Donnamour1969
- Wishin' & Hopin' by Coley
- You, Me and the Sea by JennaBennett
Favorite Shorter Fics/Oneshots (less than 10k words)
- A Little Rough by MadiDavis
- A Yoghurt Lid by impreciseotto
- An Exercise in Courage and Honesty by NobleLandMermaid
- And the World Turned by agian18
- Another White Dash by JennaBennett
- Begin Again by SprinklesTheCat
- Chaotic Christmas by Coley
- Christmas Morning by Donnamour1969
- Drunk Me (Can’t Get Over You) by again18
- High Hopes by JennaBennett
- I heard your heart say love love love by JennaBennett
- Morning After by Comfect
- New Year's Eve by Donnamour1969
- Nice Morning Too by MadiDavis
- Perfect Mess by JennaBennett
- Say Something (I'm Not Giving Up On You) by agian18
- Second Place is just First Loser by Duchess Cupcake
- Skin and Chips by Kuri333
- Slow Dancing in a Burning Room by JennaBennett
- Snaps by agian18
- The unflinchingly rigid rules of jinx by Kuri333
- This Year by JennaBennett
- Trick You Treat Me by Coley
- Valentine's Fairy Godfather by Kuri333
Favorite Fluffy Fanfics
- Begin Again by SprinklesTheCat
- Drunk Me (Can’t Get Over You) by agian18
- Gorgeous by SprinklesTheCat
- The Falls by warrior4
- The Unflinchingly Rigid Rules of Jinx by Kuri333
- This Thing Called Life (at the start and end) by warrior4
- Valentine's Fairy Godfather by Kuri333
- V-J Day by Comfect
- Wishin' and Hopin' by Coley
- You, Me and the Sea by JennaBennett
Favorite Angsty Fanfics
- A Little Rough by MadiDavis
- An Exercise in Courage and Honesty by NobleLandMermaid
- Beyond the Horizon by agian18
- Hello My Old Heart by Duchess Cupcake
- How Not To by again18
- Living in Color by JennaBennett
- Restart by agian18
- Ruin the Friendship by Duchess Cupcake
- Safe and Sound by NobleLandMermaid
- Serendipity by Sam
- Stilettos and Broken Bottles by Coley
- Unwrapped by Coley
Favorite Steamy Fanfic
- Discovery by SprinklesTheCat
- Kind of Reckless by Coley
- Nice Morning Too by MadiDavis
- Ruin the Friendship by Duchess Cupcake
- Safe and Sound by NobleLandMermaid
- Slow by agian18
- Snaps by agian18
- Stilettos and Broken Bottles by Coley
- The Twelve Days of Smutmus by agian18, Coley, Duchess Cupcake
- Trick Me Treat Me by Coley
- Unwrapped by Coley
Favorite “Under the Radar” Fanfics
go show these and every fic you enjoy some love by reviewing and leaving jellybeans!
- A Little Rough by MadiDavis
- An Exercise in Courage and Honesty by NobleLandMermaid
- Begin Again by SprinklesTheCat
- Chaotic Christmas by Coley
- Christmas Morning/New Year's Eve by Donnamour1969
- High Hopes by Jenna Bennett
- I heard your heart say love love love by JennaBennett
- Say Something (I'm Not Giving Up On You) by agian18
- Second Place is just First Loser by Duchess Cupcake
- Through the Door by Awimoweh
- Trick Me Treat Me by Coley
Favorite Moment in a Fanfic
Cosa Nostra by Coley - Pam adding, “do not fall in love,” to the list in the most rom-com trope-y move of all time
Groundhog Nights by Comfect - Karen getting hit by a truck but then is fine the next day
Hello my Old Heart by Duchess Cupcake - when Jim shows Pam his online profile. When she asks him when he became so fuckable. Jim's Raya account and Pam introducing Jim and Danny to each other
How Not To by again18: “Hi,” I started, closing my eyes and taking a deep breath. “My name is Pam Beesly. I’m an alcoholic. And I really, really don’t want to be one anymore.” and then she and Jim pour out their bottle of booze
I Heard Your Heart Say Love, Love, Love by JennaBennett - Michael holding the Team Pam sign in the window
Kind of Reckless by Coley - for burning the image of farmer Jim into my mind
Morning After by Comfect - Cutest Larisa Halpert
Office Space by Comfect - "And apparently he had mastered the art of talking and drinking through the same mouth at the same time (reportedly an ability they had gene-engineered into the inhabitants of Omicron Perseii VIII,"
Perfect Mess by JennaBennett - Kevin's protecting Pam from Roy
Ruin the Friendship by Duchess Cupcake - Pam and Jim finally hooking up again, Pam thinking about buying Katy a peace lily
Serendipity by Sam - Jim proposed Pam, Jim and Pam's wedding night
Sing Gloria by warrior4 - The most references to RL in any fic ever
Snaps by again - the moment it was published, “Come back here and f*** me like a real man", Pam daring Jim to come back and f*** her like a real man AND THEN his follow through, and did I mention Snaps? Just... all of Snaps.
Stilettos and Broken Bottles - Every word … Don't make me pick just one moment there
Unwrapped by Coley: “Can I kiss you?”, when it was finally updated after that Cliffhanger kiss
When Pam Met Jim by Donnamour1969: Pam and Jim dancing at Micheal's mother's birthday party
Favorite Reread/Discoveries of 2019
- Cardiac Care by VampiricBlood
- Error Code by Comfect
- Fathers and Daughters, Women and Men by Stablergirl
- I Know Where I Belong by callisto
- I just wanted to be Famous by stablergirl
- Layover by Annabel Winslow
- My True Love Gave to Me by time4moxie
- Observer Effect by GodInThisChilis
- One Week After by NobleLandMermaid
- Onterio by Talkative (especially in honor of Jim and Pam’s 10th wedding anniversary!)
- Open by Annabel Winslow
- Oracle Mom by time4moxie
- Out of the Fog by Kat11
- Real and Imagined by shutterbug
- S-E-A-M by nomadshan
- Shift by thirtypercent
- Sneak Preview by Peskipiksi
- Some Mornings by Duchess Cupcake
- Taking a Chance by callisto
- Talk by Annabel Winslow
- The Best Dundies Ever by shan21
- The Boy Next Door by onlyonekitchen
- The Distance and the Damage by unfold
- The Love Song of Squirrel McPants by time4moxie
- The Paper Bride by nomadshan
- The Trip by Little Comment
- Truth and Consequences by shan21
- Vanilla by Annabel Winslow
- Visibility by callisto
- Would you Still Love Me by Italian Food
Favorite Authors
- Agian18
- Celluloiddreams
- Coley
- Comfect
- Dernhelm
- Donnamour1969
- Duchess Cupcake
- JennaBennett
- Kuri333
- MadiDavis
- NobleLandMermaid
- Sam
- SprinklesTheCat
- warrior4
Most Improved Authors
- Coley
- Donnamour1969
- Duchess Cupcake “for writing the smuts!” “Obsessed with everything she writes, but entering the world of smut with a threesome is just so Dundie-worthy.”
- JennaBennett
- Sprinkles the Cat
Favorite Reviewers
- agian18
- BecauseOfYou
- Coley
- Comfect
- Duchess Cupcake
- ftmill18
- JennaBennet
- Kuri333
- Merria
- NobleLandMermaid
- SprinklesTheCat
- warrior4 (the most prolific of all reviewers!)
Member-created Dundies
Story Related
- The most bittersweet story of the year - 'An education' by Kuri333
- Most random object to be Jell-O-ed - Pam’s stun gun in Coley's Cosa Nostra
- Best unfinished - Hello my Old Heart by Duchess Cupcake
- Regency JAM - Dernhelm’s great Austen inspired “Pamela or a tale of patience and persistence”
- Give the people what they want - agian18 for Snaps
- Best Follow-Through After Being Harrassed For All of 2019 - Agian18, for finally giving us the bodysuit fic.
- The “I didn’t want to like it but the writing was too damn good” award - Pam and Ryan’s bodyshots and hook-up scenes in Stilettos and Broken Bottles by Coley
- Best sex scene: Pam and Jim in the bathroom in Stilettos and Broken Bottles by Coley
- Best Threesome: Coley, again18, and Duchess Cupcake for The Twelve Days of Smutmas
Member Related
- Juggler of the Year: agian18 for managing to keep so many fics going and actually finish them.
- Queen of Porn with Plot or Smut that makes you Think - agian18
- Always Comes Through with the FicPic, or just a really pretty picture of JKras when you need one - Ava
- Queen of Inspiration on Demand - Ava
- Queen of Holiday Fanfic - Coley
- Queen of the Most Memorable & Quotable Moments in Fanfic - Coley
- Inspiration of the year - Comfect
- Breakout star - Donnamour1969 for joining late in the year but still posting 5 fics in that time and earning several noms for fav fic and fav author in that time
- Most on point at depicting female friendships - Duchess Cupcake
- Special Achievements in Angst - Duchess Cupcake for both Hello My Old Heart and Ruin the Friendship
- Dundie for defying the odds & creating the most likable versions of Karen: everything Duchess Cupcake writes
- Biggest Twitter Flan - emxgoldstars for always being the first to like MTT tweets!
- The Lurkers, for those who don't write but are still part of the fun: HonestandCourageous, Merria, HeyItsRachiiee
- Best use of secondary characters in fic - JennaBennett
- Support and guiding star - JennaBennet
- The Thunda' from Down Unda - JennaBennett
- The "Leaving Us Wanting More" Award - MadiDavid for dropping 3 great fics last February then disappearing! (go read and review their fics, maybe they'll come back!)
- JAM Historian - NobleLandMermaid
- Lifetime Achievement: NobleLandMermaid for somehow still producing quality content year after year
- MVIP (Most Very Important Person): NobleLandMermaid, for putting up with all of us, keeping everything running so smoothly, being an amazing writer, and just being the best.
- “Member Sweep" Dundie - SprinklestheCat for being nominated for fav author, most improved author and fav reviewer
- King of Reviews - warrior4 for being by far the most prolific reviewer last year, and for writing thoughtful thorough reviews with plenty of praise but also kind constructive criticism
- Most unapologetic guilt trips given: Duchess Cupcake, Agian18, and JennaBennett; who won't just let me live.
--Admin Team on May 01, 2020 12:49 am 0 Comments