You must login (register) to review or leave jellybeans
Reviewer: emxgoldstars Signed [Report This]
Date: April 23, 2022 10:53 pm Title: Chapter 11 - The Key

UGH this is written so WELL, Max!

Author's Response: thanks Em...I really appreciate that.

Reviewer: boredhswf Signed [Report This]
Date: December 30, 2021 02:46 pm Title: Chapter 11 - The Key

"The big joke around the office was always telegraph, telephone, tell-a-Michael." God, that is so perfect.

This made me laugh too: “Oh, and Michael, I’ll tell you what I used to tell my students. You get three strikes and then you’re out.”

Ugh and Aunt Janet made me groan. Great job making her out to be the perfect caricature of a woman in Roy's family.

Author's Response:

Well that seems to be the favorite line! 

But oh so Michael.

Yeah, well this is why Randall's wife was made to be a former teacher - patience to an extent - honestly I don't know how teachers do it since there is bound to be a Michael in every class (and a Dwight, a Jim, A Meredith, a Kelly, you get the idea). Thinking about this I think I now need to go buy that children's book, A Day at DM Elementary.

I'm so glad it came across - the tone of Roy's aunt. Means well and there's love for Pam, but not a great role model.

Thanks always for your reviews. 

Reviewer: MrsKHalpert Signed 1 [Report This]
Date: December 28, 2021 07:35 am Title: Chapter 11 - The Key

Really enjoying this and hope the next chapter will be up soon!!

Author's Response:

Your wish is my command. 

Just so happened to be ready to post today. 

Thanks so much again. I'm so glad you are enjoying it.

 

Reviewer: Basscop69 Signed 1 [Report This]
Date: December 23, 2021 03:53 am Title: Chapter 11 - The Key

Ok, I’m very behind on this - but also very pleased that it meant I had several chapters to read! I’m continuing to just love this, it’s so much fun. The Pam and Michael scenes are a delight, I think I could just keep reading these even if there was no Jam (I also really like that time-travelling Michael’s main efforts on Booze Cruise were to stop what he caused: you’ve got the balance between him being completely infuriating and then his moments of sweetness, e.g. with Pam comforting him in the car, so perfect). I also love how well the inclusion of Randall works in this, and the fleshing out of his character (his wife giving Michael 3 strikes, and Pam later adopting that, is genius). Also: “Your best behavior, whatever you think that is, make it even better than that” is just the instruction Michael needs always.

But back to the Jam: Pam hearing Jim describing her as warm and funny is just exactly the moment from that conversation with Michael that I would’ve loved for her to hear, and I thought you wrote it so well with her only catching those couple of tidbits. I’m continuing to enjoy the slow build of her confusion / realisation about Jim, it feels very realistic - also lol at this being the point where Michael suddenly learns to keep a secret. Tell-a-Michael really made me chuckle. The reveal end of this chapter about Roy’s potential motivations from Janet is painful, as is the fact that Pam then tries to dismiss that because they’re getting married…again, it feels very realistic and in character, but just ouch. Come on Pam!

I for one am really glad that it’s all about the journey as it means more to read - can’t wait for the next chapter!

PS I also adored the little glimpse into Dwangela - “Monkey, looking forward to showing you who the real captain is” is just so grossly, brilliantly, Dwight.

Author's Response:

so glad you like the Pam/Micheal bits as this story is not just about the Jam relationship but about theirs too - and we'll be with them without Jim for a while (but not without thoughts of him - I promise)

Also glad you like how Randall is tied in (and his wife) - they have a bit more to come.

thanks for coming back - I do adore reviews and getting your thoughts. 

Happy holidays  

 

Reviewer: tinydundie Signed [Report This]
Date: December 16, 2021 05:02 pm Title: Chapter 11 - The Key

*telegraph, telephone, tell-a-Michael.*

BRILLIANT.

So, now I have this idea in my head that I'll never be able to get rid of that every item of clothing in my house that mysteriously disappears is something my time traveling self has stolen. Thanks a lot for that, Max.

Really enjoyed this one. I like how your S2 Pam seems to flip back and forth between wanting Jim to have feelings for her and content that things are actually settled with Roy, or seem to be. It really highlights the confusion she must have been feeling in this timeframe.

Author's Response:

Everyone (and by that I mean my three reviewers) loved that line.

You have hit on something I've also thought about and will be ad-dressed in upcoming chapter starting with the next one -and more later.

Hope it doesn't get too annoying with her flip-flopping and her not being able to give up on her relationship with Roy- but I have lots to hit upon and Pam has to be 'blind" a little bit longer even though her eyesight is now corrected.

Thanks for the review as always.  

Reviewer: darjeelingandcoke Signed [Report This]
Date: December 16, 2021 03:36 pm Title: Chapter 11 - The Key

"telegraph, telephone, tell-a-Michael." I lol'd.

You know what? I understand why it's frustrating Pam, but I think Michael deserves a little credit here. For once, he has actually learned from his mistakes and he is not digging the hole any deeper. I'm proud of him. Maybe time travel really is helping him grow?

"looked back at her husband who locked eyes with her in a silent communication that reminded Pam of the way she sometimes passed messages to Jim without ever saying a word." Ugh. OPEN YOUR EYES, PAM. Come on. You can't tell that's meaningful? *grumbles* But seriously - very true to them, and feels like something she'd be thinking about here.

That's actually kind of an interesting relationship test. Could you tell them you think you're stuck in a time warp? Would they believe you? And it's a good note working in Pam's canonical belief in ghosts here.

Oh, Michael. I half expected him to ask Pam for another drink of water here. Pam's lucky to have Gabby there - maybe between a surrogate Mom and a surrogate teacher they can get him to behave.

His point about the grill is kind of smart in a round-about way! Surely regular timeline Michael would notice that his grill was gone, it would be chaos. A whole episode on its own. Wondering if his note idea is going to end up having repercussions.

"only his birthing process was the trip through time and what he forgot was what a baby he himself had been that whole day." LOL. He really is a little boy in this chapter, in a very enjoyable way. I love his spy caper.

Ugh. Poor Pam. She really gets hope dangled right in front of her and then yanked away here. I'm always interested in her relationship with Roy's family, particularly post-Superfan episodes now that we know she's pretty comfortable with Roy's mom. Casts some of her decisions in a different light knowing how intertwined their lives were.

Author's Response:

I truly appreciate your enthusiasm for this story - so much.

That seems to be the line for this chapter - all three review mentioned it. Glad you liked it.

Michael tries to do the right thing, sometime however when he tries too hard that's when things go off the rails...not saying it's going to happen here but certainly what happened in a particular episode that had an Elvis impersonation.

Open your now with perfect vision eyes, but that's the fun of this whole experiment - to bring up all the things she hasn't been able to see.

A test yes, but there might be more to it than that and that's all I'm saying.

Hope you like Gabby, she's kind of the Beth of this story. Every story needs a good OC.

NOw I am a little behind in those superfans, in truth I half avoided if only to not uncanonize things I'd written for this... then I went and watched Booze cruise  and used a tiny bit of it (Ryan in bathroom). But I'm rectifying that now. JUst hope it doesn't bite me.

 

Thanks again for always leaving such detailed and enthusiastic reviews. 

Reviewer: warrior4 Signed [Report This]
Date: December 16, 2021 10:58 am Title: Chapter 11 - The Key

Why won't they let Michael sleep on the couch? Seems like an important detail. Curious to be sure. Telegraph, telephone, tele-Michael. Loved that line because it's just so true. Michael just can't keep a secret. He wants so much to be in on something that when he is, he wants everyone else to be in on it too. I'll give it to him for childlike wonder even if it doesn't make the the best confidant.

More conflicting thoughts with Pam. She realizes that there are some key things wrong with her relationship with Roy. He wouldn't just simply believe her if she said something seemingly off the wall, doesn't seem to get her prank loving humor, and there are issues about how they'll raise any future children. Those are some big red flags to be sure. However she's also still caught up in setting the date bliss and that excitement seems to be covering up some of those reservations. Especially when she runs into extended Anderson family. But yet even then the cracks in the relationship are still there. The memory of slamming the box of cereal in Roy's face and wondering if he set the date just to keep getting a discount on rent.

It all paints a great picture of all the thoughts bouncing around in her head right then.

Author's Response:

Trying not to slack this time....

WOULD YOU LET Michael Sleep on your pristine white couch? 

That tele- line seemed to be everyone's fave. But like you said -so true. He tries though.

Yeah Pam's stuck in her own prison of having waited so long that now that it's here she can't "see" how wrong it is. But she's not yet ready - she's got a lot more to "see".  

Always love to read your reviews. You are great at "seeing" what I'm writing. 

Thanks as always. 

 

 

 

You must login (register) to review or leave jellybeans