Reviewer: supergirlsudz Signed
Date: July 29, 2008
Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1
Hey wendolf. I've been reading this all along and have yet to leave a review and I felt bad about that. I wavered with myself whether or not to click the link and read because I know I don't particularly care for "sad" endings and the thought of Jim and Pam not ending up together makes me want to jump off the nearest balcony. But I know you're such a great writer and that would be stupid of me to miss out on this.
You have such a great grasp on Jim's voice and character. It feels real and like someone else said in a review, I was kind of happy he was okay and able to move on with his life post-Pam. Emily is a fun character, too. I like how you have sections from her POV. It helped me sympathize with her.
But, I do have to say that Pam is coming off a little out of character. I think while she does have dreams of a career in graphic design and living in a big city, deep down she is just a small town girl who wants to get married (ahem...to some guy whose name rhymes with Tim) and have a family. So, it's hard for me to disregard that. It's also hard for me to think back on the season four scenes with these two at their happiest and think that it didn't work out for them. To think that Pam has changed so much that she doesn't want Jim in her life anymore (and vice versa). I know it happens in real life all the time but part of me thinks that it's just not possible for it to happen for these two. As cheesy as that sounds.
That being said, it's still an engrossing read and while I can't say that it's super enjoyable to read, I will say that I am interested to see where you go with this.
Author's Response: Your thoughts re: Pam\'s sudden shift have been echoed by others here as well, and I totally see what you\'re saying. It is hard to imagine her going from \"Yay! Jim\'s going to propose!\" to the picture I\'ve painted. It\'s definitely a pretty major stretch. But I\'ll tell you what I\'ve told them . . . I had to force it along a bit. Perhaps I sacrificed a bit of reality in favor of a quicker moving storyline. I didn\'t want them to get engaged because I didn\'t want either of them (especially Pam) to have to call off a wedding. And the only way for them NOT to get engaged is to have them grow apart somehow. And even though I\'ve been heavy on the Pam growing apart side of things, I think Jim is feeling it, too.
I do have one argument, though, for Pam\'s sudden transformation, and it\'s a personal one. I went through a similar thing myself in my 20s, brought about by a change of surroundings and prospects for my future. And I took much of my confusion out on my then boyfriend (now wonderful husband). I was confused and overwhelmed and wondered if there was something (not necessarily someone) different out there for me. Lucky for me, my guy stuck with me through it and we\'ve had a great relationship ever since. But that was some rough going for awhile there and if he had given up? I might have given up, too. I\'m not saying that\'s how it\'s going to go in this story . . . just pointing out that I know from experience that things can sometimes change on a dime, even in a love fest like Jim and Pam.
O...kay. Now that you know WAY more about my private life than you ever wanted to know... thank you so so much for your review. I truly appreciate your honesty and very constructive thoughts.