Reviewer: BlindManCassidy Signed
Date: March 22, 2021
Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1
This might be the best chapter you’ve ever written, Basscop69.
So, we must start with Jim and Helene - where it all begins. I think I love her the most - she sees Jim as he truly is, that same little boy who loved her daughter way back when. I also feel bad for her - she’s lost everything because of her husband. Friends, family.
Next, we’ve got the two daughters. I’ve always appreciated Penny as a neutral character, but in this story, she seems more replicant of the popularized version of Larissa, which I appreciate more.
I think it’s cute that Pam was so shy to show off her wedding dress, although I can understand her and Jim’s hesitance, after all that went down the day before. And of course it’s not a dress she wanted, but one that was expensive and fancy.
I thought it was adorable how much more invested Jim was in her painted butterflies (awesome story name right there) because *she* was so much more invested in them. And then you’ve got Danny’s hesitance and purchase of paper to draw on instead. News flash, fucko: if she wanted paper, she would’ve gotten paper.
Then, just as things are going alright, we get a call from William and learn he’s refused parole.
This was the scene for me. I mean - it’s just so relatable. Watching these characters break because the father is so stubborn and can’t do what’s right for his family, ruining his relationships with them despite their attempts. I’ve been there.
And, while Danny is god knows where, then there’s Jim, who takes out the fucking cake and frosts it so that these girls can comfort there mother. While Danny is god knows where, Jim is in the kitchen helping Pam frost the cake. While Danny is god knows where, Jim is making his family-in-law and fiancée laugh and smile in this devastating time.
So it’s all the more satisfying to see Jim and Pam finally reach a place of friendship. Pam is genuinely grateful for his help, while Jim is acknowledging the bubble they’re in - they won’t mention Danny or anything that occurred last night because they desperately want to get along again. They want to be kids again.
Which can only bring us to Pam considering her relationship with Danny in comparison to Jim; the ideal, ‘perfect’ man versus Jim. The known versus the unknown. It’s a damn difficult decision, which only makes “ She ends on he loves me not.
She tells herself she's not sure who she means” all the more impactful. On the one hand - she’s not sure if her fiancée loves her or not? On the second hand - she can’t just pursue Jim and give up everything she has for a life she doesn’t know or understand (yet). On the third hand - she’s picking flowers and repeating a childhood rhyme in hopes of rekindling her love for Danny - red flags! On the fourth hand, she’s picking flowers and repeating a childhood rhyme for Jim.
This one hit close to home, Basscop69. Fanfiction at its finest.
Tears in these soulless eyes,
BlindManCassidy
(Accidentally deleted my first review, this ones a bit messier)
Author's Response:
Ahh thank you so much - that's so unbelievably kind of you to say :) I'm really glad you liked this one!
I did enjoy writing Helene and Penny in this, and some of Pam's family dynamics - and yeah, I thought the difference with Penny in this fic is that she knew Jim from before, when she was also growing up, so might be a bit less neutral towards him than she is in canon. And haha, painted butterflies would be a good story name! ('News flash, fucko' also really made me laugh. Very true though).
And yes, I wanted to show that it was Jim doing the simple stuff and just being there that made a difference, and matters so much more to Pam than big gestures - so I'm really pleased that came across!
One thing I will say, on Pam's love for Danny...she's never actually said either way whether *she* loves *him*. She's definitely very unsure that he loves her though (/knows that he doesn't, deep down...)
Thanks so much again for your lovely review :)