Jenna posted this photo on Instagram last week
Which somehow lead me to this Bustle article with John talking about the Office Olympics “medals”
“That was one of my favorite episodes of all time. I have the weirdest story about that… When we first saw the first cut of it, no one had said the phrase ‘yogurt lids.’ So in the middle of this first cut, that didn’t go to air, obviously, it’s our editor [saying ‘yogurt lids’]. So I think I’m saying, ‘And I’ll be handing out these…’ and then you hear the editor say ‘yogurt lids.’ And so the yogurt lid thing, we always laugh when we hear it.”
Though if you watch the clip, there’s definitely someone saying yogurt lids.