1 [Report This]Date: December 15, 2024 01:11 am Title: In this dark so dense we talk so soft, the way young lovers do
Love love love this. Wow!!!!
1 [Report This]Date: February 25, 2021 09:31 am Title: In this dark so dense we talk so soft, the way young lovers do
Beautiful. Very true to character!! I definitely put this on my bookshelf
1 [Report This]Date: February 24, 2021 06:28 pm Title: In this dark so dense we talk so soft, the way young lovers do
Beautiful. Very true to character!! I definitely put this on my bookshelf
1 [Report This]Date: September 06, 2018 08:43 pm Title: Why can't we give love one more chance?
I’ve read this through probably 3 or 4 times in the last month, that’s how good it is. Ugh, I just love it. You captured them so incredibly perfectly, with so much depth and emotion. Bravo.
1 [Report This]Date: September 04, 2018 05:58 am Title: In this dark so dense we talk so soft, the way young lovers do
Lovely!
1 [Report This]Date: July 21, 2018 09:16 pm Title: Why can't we give love one more chance?
“Party of My So-Called Creek Slayer” or something.
Omigod. I can't.
Date: August 08, 2017 05:30 pm Title: In this dark so dense we talk so soft, the way young lovers do
Such an incredibly sweet, emotive, tenderly detailed story. It has literally taken my breath away. It has filled the hole in their story in my mind as The Truth. Sigh.
Date: February 23, 2012 02:33 pm Title: Tears and fears and feeling proud
Home sick today and decided to reread some good old stuff. What a beautiful line this is:
She shakes her head and then he knows, and he’s there too, and her dress is blue, and her cheeks are pink, and she is weightless and happy until he hands her the heavy stone of his heart to carry.
Date: August 18, 2011 09:49 am Title: In this dark so dense we talk so soft, the way young lovers do
What a wonderful story you have written. I can't believe I missed it. That's exactly how I imagined their first date would be -- talking and kissing -- spending time together in various situations because they didn't want the night to end. Beautiful!
10 [Report This]Date: May 22, 2011 03:07 pm Title: In this dark so dense we talk so soft, the way young lovers do
I don't know how I missed this before, but dear lord, that was fantastic. I will consider this first date canon for now on!
Date: October 18, 2010 06:02 pm Title: In this dark so dense we talk so soft, the way young lovers do
What a beautiful ending to a wonderful story! I loved this, with all of the sweet moments and revelations, and the arguments and accusations that were perfectly intertwined. Thanks for giving us a glimpse into your mind's eye - *you kneel* I officially dub you welcomed into the fold of MTT writers by way of this first date story on this 18th day of October, twenty-ten *you rise*. Congratulations!
Date: October 18, 2010 11:58 am Title: In this dark so dense we talk so soft, the way young lovers do
Perfect ending! We are left with our own imagination as to where they are headed. Thank you for writing this wonderful story. I will miss it.
Date: October 18, 2010 09:37 am Title: Why can't we give love one more chance?
I am giving you a standing ovation right now in front of my computer screen. Bravo and thank you so very much.
10 [Report This]Date: October 18, 2010 09:15 am Title: In this dark so dense we talk so soft, the way young lovers do
I've been enjoying this story immensely since day one, and the final chapter did not disappoint. I loved the fact that you kept the ending (somewhat) open, and we can come to our own conclusion as to what happened later.
The best thing about this story, however, is the banter and the characterisation, which is spot-on.
Fantastic job, and I'm looking forward to reading more from you.
Date: October 18, 2010 06:53 am Title: In this dark so dense we talk so soft, the way young lovers do
After much deliberation, this is my favorite: He thinks about whispering his whole heart to her... *sigh* Makes me all swoony.
Date: October 18, 2010 05:13 am Title: In this dark so dense we talk so soft, the way young lovers do
*Dresses in black* Man oh man I'm going to miss this story SO much. It was truly awesome. I cannot begin to tell you how much I enjoyed reasing this. It was so different to anything that has been done before, and you have SUCH a way with words (which I suppose helps in your line of work ;))
I'd love to sit here and write a really helpful review, but I have NOTHING useful to say other than how great this was. How real this was. How tis is SO much like I imagined their first date to be.
If you ever feel like writing a second date series, you know - feel free ;)
I'M GOING TO MISS YOU ON A NIGHT LIKE THIS
Date: October 18, 2010 05:04 am Title: In this dark so dense we talk so soft, the way young lovers do
Oh, ivy...this is just perfect, a gloriously satisfying ending. You've achieved a delicious combination of romantic and sexy. I would most definitely be pasting the whole chap into this little box if I were to try to choose a favorite passage. Well done! ::wild applause::
P.S. Still smiling :D
10 [Report This]Date: October 18, 2010 12:15 am Title: Why can't we give love one more chance?
all good things must come to an end. I too, could read chapter after chapter of their first date, but this felt like a natural ending. loved the kiss at the door and pam inviting jim in. it's as if their date never really ended and you can leave it up to the reader to decide what happens next. thanks for making this one of my favorite "first date" fics!
Date: October 17, 2010 10:39 pm Title: In this dark so dense we talk so soft, the way young lovers do
Ooh! I love the open-ended quality of the ending. This has been an absolutely delightful ride, ivy. Never too heavy, not too fluffy, perfectly believable dialogue and details, and terrifically descriptive and well-phrased text throughout. This has been such a treat to read. Thank you for sharing with us all.
And what a bonus! The last chapter of this fic and the first of your next one posted on the same night.
Author's Response: Thank you! I really have a great affection for endings that really aren't. One of my favorite movie endings of recent years has been "Before Sunset." As soon as I decided to make this story more than just a one-shot, the end was the first thing I planned. Thank you for taking this journey with me.
Date: October 15, 2010 03:02 pm Title: Tears and fears and feeling proud
Well let's just pretend that the gate was locked in night out because of this prank and Dwight went nuts. There ya go. The memories didn't strike me as redundant. Not sure how you did that but huge kudos there. I like how quickly they're into their normal pranking fun. Hope you're planning more stories for us to enjoy as you begin to wrap this one up. PS love your song choice for the title. One of my all time favorites.
Date: October 15, 2010 06:50 am Title: Tears and fears and feeling proud
Oh, Ivy, so, SO many great things in this chapter I hardly know where to start. Yes, I do.
She shakes her head and then he knows, and he’s there too, and her dress is blue, and her cheeks are pink, and she is weightless and happy until he hands her the heavy stone of his heart to carry.
That is just gorgeous phrasing. The lilt and rhythm of it are so light and then thud ... it drops with the heavy stone of his heart. Did you craft it on purpose that way – bouncy/liliting then thud – or was that serendipity?
What had she said that night? Taking him all in? She has. He belongs to her. She has consumed him. He is Jonah and she is the whale.
So, here I was, bracing myself for the dreaded she was everything. (One of my personal pet peeves. I think it's lazy and I hate it.) But no, you come up with the Biblical Jonah. Love it!
What a great little prank they're playing on Dwight. Somehow, I like it better that they haven't even worked out all the details. And the image of Jim smiling sheepishly as Pam compimented him on how good he looks in Cherries in the Snow was awfully cute.
The only thing that I found jarring in the chapter wasn't in terms of writing style but with continuity with the show. Jim says he called Jan and had the job offer that night. But he was speaking to her in person in the parking lot, so why would he have phoned her? I read the chapter several times and that caught my attention every time.
Oh, and another thing I keep forgetting to mention. I like your choice to present the chapters in kind of an episodic manner rather than showing us EVERYTHING in the date. You allow yourself to get straight to the "good parts" and don't have to worry about a lot of filler.
So, other than my one little, anal complaint ... Pure perfection! This is definitely the best first date fic ever!
Author's Response: Thanks! I changed to have him say he called Jan later that night. In my mind, when he spoke to Jan in the parking lot, he'd been given the offer but hadn't quite made his final decision. I always thought his confession was his last ditch effort to try to find a reason to stay. I imagine after he left the office (post-episode) he called Jan and left her a voicemail saying he'd take it.
Date: October 14, 2010 06:47 pm Title: Tears and fears and feeling proud
I loved this one. It was so nice they were able to talk about the past but not have to dwell on it. I was so happy to see an update on this one. I have been missing it.
Date: October 14, 2010 02:51 pm Title: Tears and fears and feeling proud
Eeeeeeeeee the ending had me smiling and I can't quite explain why, but it did.
This line - this KILLED ME DEAD.
She thinks he’s seemed more like a man since he’s come back, and sometimes that makes her sad. She wonders if she killed the boy in him.
My heart broke becase I thinkshe did kill the boy in him - just a little anyway :(
How I have missed your fics my God!
Date: October 14, 2010 06:44 am Title: Tears and fears and feeling proud
I was hoping for an update from you today, ivy. You handled the prank well. By not spending too much time on it, you didn't detract from the focus of the story. They're coming full circle. The manner in which you had them address Casino Night was well done, too. I'm glad you didn't go Harlequin (as if you could) ;) “Yes,” he confirms, gazing down at her. “If you’d said yes, I would have stayed.” *sigh* So much time wasted, but they're regaining ground. So glad this isn't completely done yet. I'm not quite ready to let go.
Date: October 03, 2010 03:15 am Title: You're so fine, you blow my mind
Ah, mon amie. C'est tres magnifique, non? Tu es un auteur qui parle a mon coeur et qui me fait rire, tous les temps.
God, I hope that's right and my high school French hasn't failed me already...
Alright, second review as promised (and deserved) and I'll begin with my favourite quote: For such a low-key guy, she's only ever seen him with high glamour women, and there's a part of her that has always wanted to give him a little bit of shit about that. Especially the cheerleader. Really. Jim and the cheerleader. It would have been hilarious if it hadn't actually really bugged her.
I have nothing deep to say about it, just hahahahaha. So true.
I always found Pam's jealousy of Katy oddly amusing. Maybe it was because, as Pam, Jim and many others have pointed out, they looked way too similar for it not to mean something and the way she was caught putting on makeup...the scene on the Booze Cruise at the cool kids table....so hilariously high school. Maybe it was also because when Jim was jealous of Roy and Pam jealous of Karen, it wasn't entertaining at all. It was just heartbreakingly painful.
Katy was funny though. And they were so badly suited you could just laugh at it. Just like I was laughing during this because you go fancy new Beesly, asking whether she was fake or not (and not in reference to her personality)! The one thing I guess that was sad about the Katy thing was that it would have made Pam feel really inferior and if she only knew at the time how Jim saw her....but having them discuss this on their first date makes it much easier to handle.
I look forward to them switching the elevator buttons on Dwight (or something equally as impressive). I apologise if these reviews aren't as coherent as you'd like them to be, I just re-read and realised how much I really do waffle. A lot.