Reviewer: Shroom Signed 10
Date: February 03, 2007
Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1
Wow. That was incredibly beautiful, Colette. You did an amazing job of making the reader feel what Pam was feeling -- loneliness, desperation, fear, love, contentment. And your writing is elegant and evocative and... I'm out of words that start with e, so let's just go with effing perfect! There were so many lines that I loved, I couldn't possibly quote them all, but it all added up to something sublime.
I really liked the line about how the picnic "would have been full of possibility if he had been there." God, that's so true. When they're together, everything is full of possibilities -- the possibilty of fun, love, mischief, a happier life...
She wants to scream that he just has to say the word, but he might have a whole new vocabulary now.
I loved that line. Such a perfect description of her fear. Afraid that "I love you, Pam" might no longer be in his vocabulary.
And Jim saying "Invite me over" was just... guh. There may have been some swooning going on when I read that. I love how it was a command, an admission, and a plea (needing her to say something) all at the same time.
And the parallel of the scarf touching her thighs, stomach, breasts, and then later his lips following the same path was really nice. And the scratchiness of the wool & his stubble. So wonderfully sensual.
There were many other lines I loved, but I'll stop rambling and just sum up with: Amazing!
Author's Response: Elegant - I don't think you could have picked a word (with or without an E) that would make me happier! I'm really pleased Pam's state of mind resonated with you. And re: his Invite me over line - I actually originally included some description saying precisely that it was both a plea and a command, then edited it down - so I'm thrilled that it still came through. Thanks, Shroom. Much appreciate such a detailed review.