Reviewer: kells8995 Signed 10
Date: July 29, 2008
Title: Chapter 7: Chapter 7
oh Wendolf. Wow...just, wow.
First, I realize how hard this was for you to post this story, and I really applaud your efforts. It's not easy to go against the grain, so to speak, and I admire you telling the story you want to tell, regardless of what people want this story to be.
It's interesting, also - to see how an outsider can look at Jim and Pam the way we have seen them, and try to be objective about their feelings for them. I can only imagine how conflicted Emily is - seeing Jim so heartbreakingly in love with Pam, and wanting him to have her love him back, but yet wanting to be with him (did that make sense?). It's not an angle that is often (if ever?) explored, and I really love your take on it.
Regardless of the ending - you've taken great care with the characters here, and I love them both, so I really appreciate that. Of course, like everyone else hope that things don't go down like this in the "real" office universe, but I think I can handle reading a story such as this when such a talented writer is the one handling it.
Great job. I realize that at times you've been bummed about the response you've received, but you should keep your head up because you're a good writer, and even though this story hurts my heart a little bit, it doesn't mean I can't appreciate it for the wonderful job that you're doing.
Author's Response: Ah, kells . . . that\'s the kind of response I love to hear. I certainly didn\'t expect people to jump for joy over the premise of this story, but I was hoping there would be an audience of open-minded folks who could appreciate it for what it is: a totally fictional story based on totally fictional characters (what?! they\'re fictional???). And that is exactly what I\'ve seen, for the most part. I\'m thrilled with the response I\'ve been getting as of late -- constructive criticism (especially re: Pam\'s quick turnaround at Pratt, which I realize is a stretch), such nice comments about my writing, and the willingness to suspend \"reality\" for a minute and enjoy (is \"enjoy\" the right word?) a different kind of story. So thank you, thank you, thank you for appreciating what I was trying to do. And for taking the time to leave me your comments!