The 2022-23 MTT Dundie Awards!

stories/406/images/greatdundiesyear.jpg2023 marked 10 years since the finale of our favorite show and our little fandom is still going strong with over 160 new and updated stories in the last 2 years.

For the 5th time, we asked the MTT community to name a few of their favorites in many categories, plus create some recognition for their fellow MTTers. And as usual, our members more than answered the call! So here is our mega Dundies Post for 2022-23.

Table of Contents

Top Voted Categories
Under The Radar
Favorite Moments in a Fic
Favorite Rereads/Discoveries
Favorite Authors
Breakout Authors
Favorite Genre Authors
Favorite Reviewers
Member-created Dundies

We'll start off with these voted categories, where we crowned a Top 10 Overall and Top 5 in the rest. Interested in who all was nominated? Here's the full nomination form (google doc)


Favorite Stories Overall

Runner-Ups

Favorite Longer Stories (10k+ words)

  1. Hello Daddy by MrsKHalpert
  2. The greatest of these is love by Basscop69
  3. My Type On Paper by Yellowberry22
  4. Aeternum by boredhswf
  5. Hello My Old Heart by Duchess Cupcake

Runner-Ups

Favorite Shorter Stories (less than 10k words)

Runner-Ups

Favorite Fluffy Stories

  1. Any Type of Mom Really by MrsKHalpert
  2. Ordinary Doodles by Receptionitis15
  3. My First, My Last, My Everything by MrsKHalpert
  4. Up in the Air by WanderingWatchtower
  5. Whisk Me Away by MrsKHalpert

Runner-Ups

Favorite Angsty Stories

  1. The greatest of these is love by Basscop69
  2. A Deal with the Devil by Robert Dunder
  3. Hello My Old Heart by Duchess Cupcake
  4. Baby, Come Home by Graceface
  5. Don't Speak by MrsKHalpert

Runner-Ups

Favorite Steamy Stories

  1. Hello Daddy by MrsKHalpert
  2. Spell Her Name With His Tongue by InRomanovWeTrust
  3. Aeternum by boredhswf
  4. Discover Me Discovering You by Coley
  5. More Socks by MrsKHalpert

Runner-Ups

Favorite Holiday Stories

  1. Fireworks by MrsKHalpert
  2. Daddy's Birthday by MrsKHalpert
  3. Warm Gloves by Receptionitis15
  4. The Bucket List by MrsKHalpert
  5. A Dandy Daddy Christmas by Robert Dunder

Runner-Ups

back to top

Under the Radar
Fics our readers felt deserved more attention

Favorite Moments in a Fic

Drunk Jim and Pam in Darryl's Car - A Dandy Daddy Christmas by Robert Dunder

The fried chicken joke from Dwight in A Deal with the Devil by Robert Dunder

Cece's Conception - A Movie Script Ending by Coley

Cece and Pam are Okay in Aeternum by boredhswf

Jam Trying to Carry on A Conversation With Others While Trying to Get it On - Daddy's Birthday-MrsKHalpert

Jim Finding Pam in Death First by Rach3l

The reveal that Y/N is Creed in ?I?m Still Cooler Than Coley? by nicemorningtoo

The bit in "It Had to be You" by TinyDundie when Pam and Kelly catch up with Jim at the petrol/gas station in the town called Hope and she finally tells him how she feels. Absolutely wonderful moment and I often skip straight to it.

Hello My Old Heart-Duchess Cupcake: Jim and Pam Finally Giving in to the Chemistry

MrsKHalpert - Jim Ryan for recreating Jack Ryan getting a bj from his captors rather than getting tortured

Pam Deciding She Wants Jim and Not Jack Ryan - Jim Ryan-MrsKHalpert

Jim Working Pam Up and Attempting to Leave - More Socks by MrsKHalpert

Jim and Pam's Reunion-Murder in Savannah by Big Tuna

Robert California's narration in My Type on Paper by YellowBerry22

Jim Gets A Cardigan - Pam's Favorite Outfits by MrsKHalpert

The Speculum Conversation--Real Girl Talk-Tired Mom's Club-MrsKHalpert

Brick face in Special Delivery by Yellowberry22

Jim and Pam's love cactus surviving everything in "Supermarket Flowers," by Receptionitis15

The yoga scene in The Greatest of these is love by Basscop69

Surprise! Pam's Pregnant - The Long One Goes In The Hole-MrsKHalpert

Wet Jim in Waiting for You by Graceface

Pam slipping her ring off in Warm Gloves by Receptionitis15

Pam and Jim Deciding to Not End the Night ? Wildflowers by BigTuna

back to top

Favorite Rereads/Discoveries
published/last updated before 2022

MTT Classics

back to top

Favorite Authors
in order of how many nominations they received

Classic MTT Authors

back to top

Breakout Authors
in order of how many nomination they received

back to top

Favorite Genre Authors

back to top

Favorite Reviewers

Once again, by far the most mentioned reviewer is Warrior4 with a special comment "always makes the effort and always finds something nice to say"

 

back to top

Member created Dundies

Story Related

Aren?t All Chaps Assless? - YellowBerry22 for Are You A Cowboy or Cowman? Because cowboy Jim

Maury Povich Would Be Proud - Graceface for the scene in Baby Come Home where Roy finds out he?s NOT the father

Realism Award, to AmeliaHalpert for the powerful and accurate way she's explored hard hitting issues in "Everything."

Approved by Sugar Daddies for Sugar Daddies - MrsKHalpert for Hello Daddy

Most Likable Version of Karen - Hello My Old Heart-Duchess Cupcake

Someone Warn The Lourve - Receptionitis15 for Ordinary Doodles for Pam?s instagram art account pieces

Layover-Cardiac Care Memorial Award for Fic You'd Most Like to See Finished: Paradox ? Dernhelm; Wildflowers - BigTuna

Most anticipated sequel - Ruin & Rubble 2 from InRomanovWeTrust

Is That A Gun In Your Pocket? - InRomanovWeTrust for Secret Agent Bad ass Jimness

 

Member Related

Please Continue Your Stories Especially Farmer Jim - Coley

The "Will they ever finishing this brilliant story, you have us all hanging'" award - Coley for 'Discover me Discovering you', and Basscop69 for 'The Greatest of These is Love'

Best (and funniest) Karen hater - New Hogfan

Keepin It Rollin' Award, to MrsKHalpert for coming up with new stories when updates have slowed down.

Best CoAuthors - Anon Pls - MrsKHalpert and Robert Dunder

Hardest working beta - Robert Dunder

Most missed author - Yellowberry22

 

Thanks everyone for nominating and voting! We'll see you next year!

Other Dundie Awards: 2021 | 2020 | 2019 | 2018