Reviewer: Little Comment Signed
Date: January 27, 2009
Title: Chapter 7: Chapter 7
In the attempt to suck just a little less...
So I'm going to share with you a little tale. (Compliments are coming shortly thereafter and are related, but feel free to skip ahead.) I really hated that speech of Alex's in this episode. Not because I hate Alex, at all, but more Jim and Pam's stunned/horrified reactions - like, what? You two haven't discussed the possibility of Pam staying in New York, in all your hours of talking? Something is pretty flawed here, kids.
You, however, have taken an element of the show that I hated and made it really work here. That's a feat and I give you all praise due. Plus, those last two lines of the chapter...if they were meant to be funny I apologize, because I cringed in that "oh, Jim...you just don't get it" kind of way. I hope that comes across as complimentary as I intended.
Okay, enough of Ms. Beets' endless prattling. This is pretty great, my friend.
And Strong Bad is fantastic. Come on, fhqwhgads. I know I'm not reinventing the wheel with anything I write, but I do appreciate the funny.
Author's Response:
I'd never thought of that before. I was just trying to make that scene fit within the context of my fic, but now thanks to you I realize that it didn't originally fit within the context of the show! Hmm... Maybe I'm right and the writers are wrong. But I will say one thing about your rationale for hating the stunnedness: since when have Pam and Jim ever been good at talking about anything important? Wasn't that pretty much the crux of three seasons of show?
That is what the last two lines were meant to elicit. A cringe and maybe an awkward laugh (possibly a bit like the actual show).