Thank you everyone who nominated and voted for stories for our (much belated) 2022-23 Dundies awards. Here are the results for Favorite overall stories!

Favorite Stories Overall

• 1. Hello Daddy by MrsKHalpert
• 2. Ordinary Doodles by Receptionitis15
• 2. The greatest of these is love by Basscop69
• 2. Aeternum by boredhswf
• 2. Hello My Old Heart by Duchess Cupcake
• 6. A Deal with the Devil by Robert Dunder
• 6. Moved on by Kuri333
• 8. Ladies and Gentlemen, Mr Duncan Halpert by MrsKHalpert
• 8. Up in the Air by WanderingWatchtower
• 10. Wildflowers by BigTuna

Runner-Ups

• Beyond the Blackboard: Year Two by WanderingWatchtower
• Elysian by boredhswf
• Everything Feels Like The Movies by Yellowberry22
• Murder in Savannah by BigTuna
• Silver Wings by warrior4

 

For the full Dundie Awards please visit this page

--MTT Admins on July 31, 2024 01:22 pm 0 Comments

We're a mere month away from Christmas Eve and you know what that means: time for some Holiday Fics!
A similar but more casual take on the secret Santa Santa fic exchanges of the past, everyone is invited to submit some Holiday/Winter elements they'd like to see in a fic. Elements can be things like objects and activities associated with this time of year, a quote or a song lyrics, or even themes and plot points like Jim & Pam's first Christmas together or a Dunder Mifflin New Year's party etc.
Once we have a good variety of elements, we'll email/message any interested writers 5 elements with the challenge of including at least 3 in your fic (you also have the option of going Challenge mode, getting 8 elements and incorporating 5). The faster people submit elements the faster we can get a good list to send out to everyone so submit today!
Holiday Fic Submission/Sign-up form

--MTT Admins on November 24, 2023 09:37 am 0 Comments

"Well I've been kinda going through a rough patch. The whole year actually." This Michael Scott quote pretty much sums up 2020, but one silver lining to this sh*tstorm of a year is quarantine and lockdowns led to lots and lots of great fanfic with over 240 new and updated stories!

As we've done the last couple years, we asked the MTT community to name a few of their favorites in many categories, plus create some recognition for their fellow MTTers. And this year, our member more than answered the call, so much so we've create a whole separate page! For the sake of our homepage, in this news post we'll only announce the Top Voted Fics, for all other award please head to the 2020 MTT Dundie Awards Page .

Jump directly to these awards on the Dundies Page:

Top Voted Categories
Under The Radar
Favorite Moments in a Fic
Favorite Rereads/Discoveries
Favorite Authors
Breakout Authors
Favorite Genre Authors
Favorite Reviewers
Member-created Dundies

Top Voted Categories

This year we did things a little different and asked people to voted in a handful of categories. We'll start off with these voted categories, where we crowned a Top 15 Overall and Top 10 in the rest.

Favorite Fics Overall of 2020

• 1. Aeternum by boredhswf
• 2. Virtus by boredhswf
• 3. Hello My Old Heart by Duchess Cupcake
• 3. Murder in Savannah by BigTuna
• 5. folklore by Collab - BigTuna, Coley, Duchess Cupcake, boredhswf, agian18, JennaBennett, SprinklesTheCat
• 5. Letters, Numbers, and the Spaces Between by BigTuna
• 7. Beyond the Blackboard by WanderingWatchtower
• 7. Rainbow's BMW by ThePinkButterfly
• 9. At the end of the day, you just gotta jump by Basscop69
• 9. How Not To by agian18
• 9. I'm the only one who needed saving by agian18
• 9. You, Me and the Sea by JennaBennett
• 13. 10 Hotel Rooms by Donnamour1969
• 13. Sketchbooks and Wine by boredhswf
• 13. The Oxford Comma Can Suck It by Coley

Runner-Ups

• Bookstore Girl by beth9501
• Cosa Nostra by Coley
• It Had Nothing to Do with Peanut Butter by agian18
• It would've been you by Basscop69
• Quarantine by Donnamour1969
• Slow by agian18
• Ultimate by Collab - WanderingWatchtower, emxgoldstars, beth9501, nicemorningtoo, ThePinkButterfly

Favorite Longer Fics (10k+ words)

• 1 Aeternum by boredhswf
• 2 Virtus by boredhswf
• 3 Hello My Old Heart by Duchess Cupcake
• 3 Beyond the Blackboard by WanderingWatchtower
• 5 folklore by Collab - BigTuna, Coley, Duchess Cupcake, boredhswf, agian18, JennaBennett, SprinklesTheCat
• 6 Letters, Numbers, and the Spaces Between by BigTuna
• 7 Murder in Savannah by BigTuna
• 7 Rainbow's BMW by ThePinkButterfly
• 9 At the end of the day, you just gotta jump by Basscop69
• 9 Cosa Nostra by Coley

Runner-ups

• How Not To by agian18
• I'm the only one who needed saving by agian18
• It would've been you by Basscop69
• Silver Wings by warrior4
• You, Me and the Sea by JennaBennett

Favorite Shorter Fics (up to 10k words)

• 1 New Year's Day by boredhswf
• 2 A Teapot Full of Hope by Dernhelm
• 2 The Oxford Comma Can Suck It by Coley
• 4 It Had Nothing to Do with Peanut Butter by agian18
• 4 Postcards by BigTuna
• 4 The Swimsuit by SprinklesTheCat
• 7 As You Wish by NobleLandMermaid
• 7 Christmas Tied by BigTuna
• 7 pancakes for dinner by agian18
• 7 Sketchbooks and Wine by boredhswf
  

Runner-Ups

• A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood by agian18
• Fun Run Cool Down by SprinklesTheCat
• Love Ain't by JennaBennett
• Subway Girl by homemadejam
• Tears Making Tracks by JennaBennett
• Why Put Out A Fire When It's Still Burning by agian18

Favorite Fluff

• 1 Beyond the Blackboard by WanderingWatchtower
• 2 Rainbow's BMW by ThePinkButterfly
• 2 You, Me and the Sea by JennaBennett
• 4 Bookstore Girl by beth9501
• 4 The Oxford Comma Can Suck It by Coley
• 6 I Think He Knows by SprinklesTheCat
• 7 JAM 6.0 by DoomGoose
• 7 Kind of Reckless by Coley
• 9 Date Line by Comfect
• 9 Ultimate by Collab - WanderingWatchtower, emxgoldstars, beth9501, nicemorningtoo, ThePinkButterfly

Runner-ups:

• A First Time for Everything by WanderingWatchtower
• All My Love and More by ThePinkButterfly
• As You Wish by NobleLandMermaid
• I Think I Am... by Mixedberries2020
• It would've been you by Basscop69
• Paint It Red by JennaBennett
• Pam 6.0 by DoomGoose
• The Receptionist Reflex by darjeelingandcoke

Favorite Angst

• 1 Hello My Old Heart by Duchess Cupcake
• 2 How Not To by agian18
• 2 Virtus by boredhswf
• 4 Sketchbooks and Wine by boredhswf
• 5 It would've been you by Basscop69
• 5 Murder in Savannah by BigTuna
• 5 Surfacing by NobleLandMermaid
• 8 Cosa Nostra by Coley
• 9 As Far As First Dates Go by BigTuna
• 9 Begged and Borrowed Time by WanderingWatchtower

Runner-ups

• A Teapot Full of Hope by Dernhelm
• I'm the only one who needed saving by agian18
• In The Loneliness by JennaBennett
• Love Ain't by JennaBennett
• What's Ours by darjeelingandcoke

Favorite Steam

• 1 folklore by Collab - BigTuna, Coley, Duchess Cupcake, boredhswf, agian18, JennaBennett, SprinklesTheCat
• 2 Slow by agian18
• 3 Aeternum by boredhswf
• 4 The Oxford Comma Can Suck It by Coley
• 4 The Swimsuit by SprinklesTheCat
• 6 As Far As First Dates Go by BigTuna
• 6 The Twelve Days of Smutmas by Collab - Duchess Cupcake, Coley, again18
• 6 What, like it's hard? by agian18
• 9 10 Hotel Rooms by Donnamour1969
• 9 illicit affairs by NobleLandMermaid

Runner-ups

• Beyond the Blackboard by WanderingWatchtower
• Christmas Tied by BigTuna
• The Unicorn by BigTuna

Thank you all who voted in these categories!

And again, for the rest of the awards please head to our 2020 MTT Dundies Awards Page


--Dundies Committee on April 30, 2021 11:55 pm 2 Comments

We closed out the 2010s with another fantastic year at the archive. We saw 125 new and updated stories in 2019 and with them many great quotes and swoonworthy moments. We asked our members to name a few of their favorites in several categories, as well as to show recognition to their fellow MTTers. So without further ado, The 2019 Dundies!

Favorite Overall Fanfics

• A Dollar Short by Comfect
• A Little Rough by MadiDavis
• An Education by Kuri333
• An Exercise in Courage and Honest by NobleLandMermaid
• Another White Dash by JennaBennett
• Begin Again by SprinklesTheCat
• Beyond the Horizon by agian18
• Christmas Visitors by Duchess Cupcake
  
• Cosa Nostra by Coley
  
• Drunk Me (Can't Get Over You) by agian18
• Engaged Ain't Married by Donnamour1969
• Gorgeous by SprinklesTheCat
• Groundhog Nights by Comfect
• Hello My Old Heart by Duchess Cupcake
• Here's a Hypothetical by Mel Like Mellow
• High Hopes by JennaBennett
• Holiday Rendezvous by NobleLandMermaid
• How Not To by agian18 
• Journals of a Stay-at-Home-Dad by warrior4
• Kind of Reckless by Coley 
• Living In Color by JennaBennett
• More (Than That) by celluloiddreams
• More Than a Day, More Than a Word by NobleLandMermaid
• Morning After by Comfect
• My Office Gave To Me by warrior4
• Nice Morning Too by MadiDavis
• Office Space by Comfect
• Perfect Mess by JennaBennett
• Restart by agian18 
• Ruin the Friendship by Duchess Cupcake
• Safe and Sound by NobleLandMermaid
• Say Something (I'm Not Giving Up On You) by agian18
• Serendipity by Sam
• Skin and Chips by Kuri333
• Snaps by agian18 
• Stilettos and Broken Bottles (Spinning Around in Circles) by Coley
• The Unflinchingly Rigid Rules of Jinx by Kuri333
• This Thing Called Life by warrior4
• This Year by JennaBennett
• Trick me, treat me by Coley
• Unwrapped by Coley
• Valentine's Fairy Godfather by Kuri333
• V-J Day by Comfect
• When Pam Met Jim by Donnamour1969
• Wishin' and Hopin' by Coley 
• You Me and the Sea by JennaBennett
  

Favorite Longer Fics (10k+ Words)

• All Along it was a Fever by SprinklesTheCat
• Beyond the Horizon by agian18
• Cosa Nostra by Coley
• Crazy Night in Philly by misery crush
• Engaged Ain't Married by Donnamour1969
• Groundhog Nights by Comfect 
• Hello My Old Heart by Duchess Cupcake
  
• Here's a Hypothetical by Mel Like Mellow
• How Not To by agian18
• Kind of Reckless by Coley 
• Living in Color by Jenna Bennet 
• More Than a Day, More Than a Word by NobleLandMermaid
  
• Notices by Comfect
• Office Space by Comfect
• Restart by agian18
  
• Ruin the Friendship by Duchess Cupcake
  
• Safe and Sound by NobleLandMermaid
  
• Serendipity by Sam
• Slow by agian18
• Stilettos and Broken Bottles by Coley
  
• The Romantic History of Jim Halpert by SprinklestheCat
  
• This Thing Called Life by warrior4
• Unwrapped by Coley 
• Waiting in the Sun by WishYouWould
• When Pam Met Jim by Donnamour1969
• Wishin' & Hopin' by Coley
• You, Me and the Sea by JennaBennett
  

Favorite Shorter Fics/Oneshots (less than 10k words)

• A Little Rough by MadiDavis
• A Yoghurt Lid by impreciseotto
• An Exercise in Courage and Honesty by NobleLandMermaid
• And the World Turned by agian18
• Another White Dash by JennaBennett
• Begin Again by SprinklesTheCat
• Chaotic Christmas by Coley
• Christmas Morning by Donnamour1969
• Drunk Me (Can’t Get Over You) by again18
• High Hopes by JennaBennett
• I heard your heart say love love love by JennaBennett
• Morning After by Comfect
• New Year's Eve by Donnamour1969
• Nice Morning Too by MadiDavis
• Perfect Mess by JennaBennett
• Say Something (I'm Not Giving Up On You) by agian18
• Second Place is just First Loser by Duchess Cupcake
• Skin and Chips by Kuri333
• Slow Dancing in a Burning Room by JennaBennett
• Snaps by agian18
• The unflinchingly rigid rules of jinx by Kuri333
• This Year by JennaBennett
• Trick You Treat Me by Coley
• Valentine's Fairy Godfather by Kuri333
  

Favorite Fluffy Fanfics

• Begin Again by SprinklesTheCat 
• Drunk Me (Can’t Get Over You) by agian18
• Gorgeous by SprinklesTheCat
• The Falls by warrior4
• The Unflinchingly Rigid Rules of Jinx by Kuri333
• This Thing Called Life (at the start and end) by warrior4
• Valentine's Fairy Godfather by Kuri333
• V-J Day by Comfect
• Wishin' and Hopin' by Coley
• You, Me and the Sea by JennaBennett 
  

Favorite Angsty Fanfics

• A Little Rough by MadiDavis
• An Exercise in Courage and Honesty by NobleLandMermaid
• Beyond the Horizon by agian18
• Hello My Old Heart by Duchess Cupcake
• How Not To by again18
• Living in Color by JennaBennett
• Restart by agian18
• Ruin the Friendship by Duchess Cupcake 
• Safe and Sound by NobleLandMermaid
• Serendipity by Sam
• Stilettos and Broken Bottles by Coley 
• Unwrapped by Coley
  

Favorite Steamy Fanfic

• Discovery by SprinklesTheCat
• Kind of Reckless by Coley
• Nice Morning Too by MadiDavis
• Ruin the Friendship by Duchess Cupcake
• Safe and Sound by NobleLandMermaid
• Slow by agian18
• Snaps by agian18
• Stilettos and Broken Bottles by Coley
• The Twelve Days of Smutmus by agian18, Coley, Duchess Cupcake
• Trick Me Treat Me by Coley 
• Unwrapped by Coley

Favorite “Under the Radar” Fanfics
go show these and every fic you enjoy some love by reviewing and leaving jellybeans!

• A Little Rough by MadiDavis
• An Exercise in Courage and Honesty by NobleLandMermaid
• Begin Again by SprinklesTheCat
• Chaotic Christmas by Coley 
• Christmas Morning/New Year's Eve by Donnamour1969
• High Hopes by Jenna Bennett
  
• I heard your heart say love love love by JennaBennett
• Say Something (I'm Not Giving Up On You) by agian18
• Second Place is just First Loser by Duchess Cupcake
• Through the Door by Awimoweh
• Trick Me Treat Me by Coley

Favorite Moment in a Fanfic

Cosa Nostra by Coley - Pam adding, “do not fall in love,” to the list in the most rom-com trope-y move of all time

Groundhog Nights by Comfect - Karen getting hit by a truck but then is fine the next day

Hello my Old Heart by Duchess Cupcake - when Jim shows Pam his online profile. When she asks him when he became so fuckable. Jim's Raya account and Pam introducing Jim and Danny to each other

How Not To by again18: “Hi,” I started, closing my eyes and taking a deep breath. “My name is Pam Beesly. I’m an alcoholic. And I really, really don’t want to be one anymore.” and then she and Jim pour out their bottle of booze

I Heard Your Heart Say Love, Love, Love by JennaBennett - Michael holding the Team Pam sign in the window

Kind of Reckless by Coley - for burning the image of farmer Jim into my mind

Morning After by Comfect - Cutest Larisa Halpert

Office Space by Comfect - "And apparently he had mastered the art of talking and drinking through the same mouth at the same time (reportedly an ability they had gene-engineered into the inhabitants of Omicron Perseii VIII,"

Perfect Mess by JennaBennett - Kevin's protecting Pam from Roy

Ruin the Friendship by Duchess Cupcake - Pam and Jim finally hooking up again, Pam thinking about buying Katy a peace lily 

Serendipity by Sam - Jim proposed Pam, Jim and Pam's wedding night

Sing Gloria by warrior4 - The most references to RL in any fic ever

Snaps by again - the moment it was published, “Come back here and f*** me like a real man", Pam daring Jim to come back and f*** her like a real man AND THEN his follow through, and did I mention Snaps? Just... all of Snaps.

Stilettos and Broken Bottles - Every word … Don't make me pick just one moment there

Unwrapped by Coley: “Can I kiss you?”, when it was finally updated after that Cliffhanger kiss

When Pam Met Jim by Donnamour1969: Pam and Jim dancing at Micheal's mother's birthday party

Favorite Reread/Discoveries of 2019

• Cardiac Care by VampiricBlood
• Error Code by Comfect
• Fathers and Daughters, Women and Men by Stablergirl
• I Know Where I Belong by callisto
• I just wanted to be Famous by stablergirl
• Layover by Annabel Winslow
• My True Love Gave to Me by time4moxie
• Observer Effect by GodInThisChilis
• One Week After by NobleLandMermaid
• Onterio by Talkative (especially in honor of Jim and Pam’s 10th wedding anniversary!)
• Open by Annabel Winslow
• Oracle Mom by time4moxie
• Out of the Fog by Kat11
• Real and Imagined by shutterbug
• S-E-A-M by nomadshan
• Shift by thirtypercent
• Sneak Preview by Peskipiksi
• Some Mornings by Duchess Cupcake
• Taking a Chance by callisto
• Talk by Annabel Winslow
• The Best Dundies Ever by shan21
• The Boy Next Door by onlyonekitchen
• The Distance and the Damage by unfold
• The Love Song of Squirrel McPants by time4moxie
• The Paper Bride by nomadshan
• The Trip by Little Comment 
• Truth and Consequences by shan21
• Vanilla by Annabel Winslow
• Visibility by callisto
• Would you Still Love Me by Italian Food
  

Favorite Authors

• Agian18
• Celluloiddreams
• Coley
• Comfect
• Dernhelm
• Donnamour1969
• Duchess Cupcake
• JennaBennett
• Kuri333
• MadiDavis
• NobleLandMermaid
• Sam
• SprinklesTheCat
• warrior4
  

Most Improved Authors

• Coley
• Donnamour1969
• Duchess Cupcake “for writing the smuts!” “Obsessed with everything she writes, but entering the world of smut with a threesome is just so Dundie-worthy.” 
• JennaBennett
• Sprinkles the Cat

Favorite Reviewers

• agian18
• BecauseOfYou
• Coley
• Comfect
• Duchess Cupcake
• ftmill18
• JennaBennet
• Kuri333
• Merria
• NobleLandMermaid
• SprinklesTheCat
• warrior4 (the most prolific of all reviewers!)
  

Member-created Dundies

Story Related

• The most bittersweet story of the year - 'An education' by Kuri333
• Most random object to be Jell-O-ed - Pam’s stun gun in Coley's Cosa Nostra
• Best unfinished - Hello my Old Heart by Duchess Cupcake
• Regency JAM - Dernhelm’s great Austen inspired “Pamela or a tale of patience and persistence”
• Give the people what they want - agian18 for Snaps
• Best Follow-Through After Being Harrassed For All of 2019 - Agian18, for finally giving us the bodysuit fic.
• The “I didn’t want to like it but the writing was too damn good” award - Pam and Ryan’s bodyshots and hook-up scenes in Stilettos and Broken Bottles by Coley
• Best sex scene: Pam and Jim in the bathroom in Stilettos and Broken Bottles by Coley
• Best Threesome: Coley, again18, and Duchess Cupcake for The Twelve Days of Smutmas
  

Member Related

• Juggler of the Year: agian18 for managing to keep so many fics going and actually finish them.
• Queen of Porn with Plot or Smut that makes you Think - agian18
• Always Comes Through with the FicPic, or just a really pretty picture of JKras when you need one - Ava
• Queen of Inspiration on Demand - Ava
• Queen of Holiday Fanfic - Coley
• Queen of the Most Memorable & Quotable Moments in Fanfic - Coley
• Inspiration of the year - Comfect
• Breakout star - Donnamour1969 for joining late in the year but still posting 5 fics in that time and earning several noms for fav fic and fav author in that time 
• Most on point at depicting female friendships - Duchess Cupcake
• Special Achievements in Angst - Duchess Cupcake for both Hello My Old Heart and Ruin the Friendship
• Dundie for defying the odds & creating the most likable versions of Karen: everything Duchess Cupcake writes
• Biggest Twitter Flan - emxgoldstars for always being the first to like MTT tweets!
• The Lurkers, for those who don't write but are still part of the fun: HonestandCourageous, Merria, HeyItsRachiiee
• Best use of secondary characters in fic - JennaBennett
• Support and guiding star - JennaBennet
• The Thunda' from Down Unda - JennaBennett
• The "Leaving Us Wanting More" Award - MadiDavid for dropping 3 great fics last February then disappearing! (go read and review their fics, maybe they'll come back!)
  
• JAM Historian - NobleLandMermaid
• Lifetime Achievement: NobleLandMermaid for somehow still producing quality content year after year
• MVIP (Most Very Important Person): NobleLandMermaid, for putting up with all of us, keeping everything running so smoothly, being an amazing writer, and just being the best.
• “Member Sweep" Dundie - SprinklestheCat for being nominated for fav author, most improved author and fav reviewer
  
• King of Reviews - warrior4 for being by far the most prolific reviewer last year, and for writing thoughtful thorough reviews with plenty of praise but also kind constructive criticism
• Most unapologetic guilt trips given: Duchess Cupcake, Agian18, and JennaBennett; who won't just let me live.

Thank you everyone for your nominations, your patience as this list was complied, and for just making MTT a great place to be!


--Admin Team on May 01, 2020 12:49 am 0 Comments

Long ago we asked our users to nominate stories and MTT members for for 2018 Dundie awards! Now that we’re halfway through the year, let’s go back in time and remember some of the best of 2018 (totally not because someone didn’t get their act together for 6 months! 😆)

And now the 2018 MoreThanThat Dundie Awards!

Favorite Overall Fanfics

• After It Airs by Steph 
• Always One Foot on the Ground by Coley 
• Anywhere But Here by NobleLandMermaid
• Crazy Night in Philly by misery crush
• Invincible Summer by shutterbug
  
• Letters, Numbers, and the Spaces Between by BigTuna
• One Week After by NobleLandMermaid
• Practical Magic by Coley
• Restart by again18
• Safe and Sound by NobleLandMermaid
• Slow by agian18 
• Sociology 101 by BigTuna
• Stay and Fight by BigTuna
• the things that make us you and me by BigTuna
• This Thing Called Life by warrior4
• Unwrapped by Coley
• Waiting in the Sun by WishYouWould
• Wake Me Up by again18
• Wherever I’m With You by Coley
• Honorable Mention to Squirrel McPants by time4moxie (“I reread it 6 times in 2018 does that count?”)

Favorite Long Fics (10k+ words)

• Always One Foot on the Ground by Coley
• Anywhere But Here by NobleLandMermaid
• Beyond the Horizon by agian18
• Crazy Night in Philly by misery crush
• Invincible Summer by shutterbug
• Letters, Numbers, and the Spaces Between by BigTuna
• One Week After by NobleLandMermaid
• Practical Magic by Coley
• Restart by again18
• Safe and Sound by NobleLandMermaid
• Slow by agian18
• Sociology 101 by BigTuna
• Terra Incognita by Comfect
• The Explosion (and the aftermath) by SprinklesTheCat
• the things that make us you and me by BigTuna
• This Thing Called Life by warrior4
• Unwrapped by Coley
• Waiting in the Sun by WishYouWould
• Wake Me Up by again18
• Wherever I’m With You by Coley

Favorite shorter fics/oneshots (less than 10k words)

• 3:27 PM Sydney by BigTuna
• After It Airs by Steph
• Bears, Beets,...Beach? By dwangela
• Black & White, Chocolate & Crème by again18
• Chaotic Christmas by Coley
• Christmas Castle by warrior4
• Fourteen Voicemails left on the night of June 10th by elephantskeleton
• If the Fates Allow by nqllisi
• No Pain, No Gain by Rach3l
• Nonverbal by BigTuna
• Peppermint by dwangela
• Stay and Fight by BigTuna
• Some Mornings by Duchess Cupcake
• Theirs by Duchess Cupcake
• Yours by dwangela

Favorite Fluffy Fanfic

• Chaotic Christmas by Coley
• Crazy Night in Philly by miserycrush
• Golden by dwangela
• Expiration Dates by shutterbug
• If the Fates Allow by nqllisi
• It’s a Date by WishYouWould
• Life's No Fun Without a Good Scare by Duchess Cupcake
• Robe by BigTuna
• The Supermarket at 2AM by Pan_Cake_Cats
• Wherever I’m With You by Coley

Favorite Angsty Fanfic

• Beyond the Horizon by agian18
• False Claims by Rach3l
• Hello My Old Heart by Duchess Cupcake
• Restart by agian18
• Safe and Sound by NobleLandMermaid
• Sin Aesthetics by Rach3l
• Slow by agian18
• Stay and Fight by BigTuna
• Theirs by Duchess Cupcake
• Unwrapped by Coley
• Wake Me Up by agian18
• Yours by dwangela

Favorite Steamy Fanfic

• Always One Foot on the Ground by Coley
• Black & White, Chocolate & Crème by agian18
• Crazy Night in Philly by miserycrush
• House Call by Coley
• It's a Date by WishYouWould
• Nonverbal by BigTuna
• Slow by agian18 7
• Stay and Fight by BigTuna
• Unwrapped by Coley
• What it Looks Like by BigTuna

Favorite Moment in a Fanfic

• After It Airs: Seeing Steph come back with a great Toby fic
• Always One Foot on the Ground (Coley): “I want you to third date me.”
• Always One Foot on the Ground: Jim explaining to Pam why he likes her green shirt and yes, Karen is pretty, but he doesn’t remember anything she wore. 😊
• Beyond the Horizon (agian18): Pam being held together with duct tape and thinking about Jim not getting garlic bread
• “this isn’t bitch beer, Beesly” from Crazy Night in Philly (miserycrush)
• Invincible Summer (shutterbug): That moment I knew I would reread it so that I could capture everything that I missed not knowing what I didn't know.
• Nonverbal (BigTuna): at the end where Jim finally says hi.
• Peppermint: When Dwangela taught me a new party game and described the most sensual "tasted like..." kiss I've read here
• “Everything in Practical Magic (Coley) was adorable.”
• in Restart (agian18) when Pam remembers she bought Jim the tie with crabs on it
• Safe and Sound (NobleLandMermaid): This one is tough because there are so many great Moments, but probably when Pam and Jim are washing dishes together and when they arrive at Schrute Farms
• Unwrapped (Coley): When Pam and Jim are playing twenty questions and we had a two-week cliffhanger after Jim asked, ""Can I kiss you?""
• Unwrapped (Coley): When Pam slipped and fell and Jim exclaimed “You went down hard!” Legit LOL’d When Pam replied “That’s what she said.” (On and everything else about that fic)
• From “Unwrapped,” the entire “Roy’s a fucking idiot” moment.
• Wake Me Up (agian18): Pam shows up at Jim's door in Stamford,
• Wake Me Up (agian18): Jim and Pam ordering a pizza while drunk on Valentine’s Day
• Wherever I'm With You (Coley): “Football doesn't have bases, Dad” (two votes for this)

Favorite Authors

• Again18
• Coley
• Comfect 
• Duchess Cupcake 
• Miserycrush
• NobleLandMermaid 
• Rach3l
• Shutterbug
• warrior4
• WishYouWould

Most Improved Author

• Again18 (“I look up to her writing and Slow with every chapter just got better and better.”)
• BigTuna
• Coley (comment: “I know she has written before but this is the first I’ve seen her work so it’s an improvement to me!”)
• miserycrush
• “Honestly me, misery crush, without this website I wouldn't be writing like I am or have the confidence to write with all the encouragement this website gives me.”
• SprinklesTheCat
• warrior4

Favorite reviewers

• agian18
• BecauseOfYou
• Clover
• Coley 2
• Comfect
• DoctorCinderella
• DuchessCupcake
• shutterbug
• SprinklesTheCat
• warrior4 (note from one nominator: “literally reviews every chapter, the date it is updated and is and amazing reviewer. Scared me at first not gonna lie, but talk me to take the pointers and make my story better which it has become.”)

Create your own Dundie category!

Story related

• Best Baby Jam: Waiting in the Sun
• Best “I really wanna hate what you did there but I’m too busy crying” Fic: Invincible Summer 
• Best Phone Steam: Always One Foot on the Ground
• Best Unfinished: Hello Old Heart
• Bravest Storytelling: Shutterbug for "Invincible Summer"
• Cutest JAM Crazy Night in Philly
• Most Creative AU (Real AU; not wildly canon divergent): No Pain, No Gain by Rach3l, Safe and Sound NLM, A Quiet War Comfect, Crazy Night in Philly miserycrush
• Sexiest JAM: Slow
• Stories from Left Field: False Claims, Always One Foot on the Ground and In Plain Sight.

Member related

• Always Down to Chat: Warrior4
• Better Late Than Never award: NobleLandMermaid (thank you friends 😆)
• Best Beta: Because of You
• Best Supporting Role in a Drunk Chat: Mr. Agian18 - I know this probably can't happen, but it still makes me laugh and deserves some sort of recognition
• Bolt of Lighting Award for Coley for being a new writer at MTT this year, but one who writes great stories and reviews
• Everyone's mom on the sidelines, waiting to give out a juicebox and a bag of carrots: Clover; Truly one of the kindest people in the fandom
• Most Supportive Cheerleader/Mom on the Sidelines - Clover
• ISO-9000 Canon Compliance award: warrior4
• Most Creative JAM: Rach3l for her great occasionally supernatural AUs 
• Most Time Spent on a Guilt Trip to Get Others to Update - Duchess Cupcake, SprinklesTheCat, Merria
• Now watch me WIP; now watch me Nae Nae award: agian18
• Holy Water Award: again18
• Honorary Einstein for Comfect for engaging stories that one quite often really has to pay close attention to in order to fully understand and insightful and helpful reviews. 
• Owning the Holiday Fic subgenre: Coley
• Steamy Oneshot Queen: BigTuna (come back to us girl!) 
• The only reason I go on Twitter, a person who posts daily inspirations and lovelies about Pam and Jim – Pamelasjimothy (now pamelajimothy)
• Website Queen: NobleLandMermaid

Thank you everyone who filled out a nomination form and congrats to all Dundie recipients!

--Admin Team on June 24, 2019 09:45 pm 0 Comments

In 2018 we continued to see a revitalized MTT improve and grow! We introduced fans new and old to a variety of fics with our Month of Fic Recs, held our 2nd ever writing contest, brought fun Office content and graphics to our social media and more!

We are also having our first ever MTT Dundie awards! Review all the 2018 fics here (google spreadsheet) and then go nominate your faves for different awards plus make up your own! MTT Dundie Nomination Form.

Now what you're all waiting for, archive stats and rankings!

2018 By The Numbers

• Over 2.6 million hits! (69% percent increase over 2017, nice!)
• 154 new members
• 22 new authors
• 99 New and Updated Stories
• 10 updated and 89 all new
• 1633 Reviews (nearly twice as many as 2017!)
• 2900+ epub downloads (over twice as many as 2017)
• Over 1 million words added! (1,097,688 to be exact)
• 58% more words added than in 2017

Stories with Most Hits in 2018 (archive wide)
- new/updated in 2018 in bold italics, new in 2017 in italics

1. Wake Me Up by agian18
2. Love, loyalty, friendship by Rach3l
3. Terra Incognita by Comfect
4. Words Left Unsaid by Rach3l
5. Slow by agian18
6. Distance Learning by time4moxie
7. Tomorrow's Gonna Be a Brighter Day by Rach3l
8. Nearing the Edge by girl7
9. Turnabout's Fair Play by ficklevillain
10. Why Albany in February is Like Paris in April by Mr Bill
11. Expressions in Emoticons by NobleLandMermaid
12. Only by girl7
13. Office Porn: Erotic Tales of the Dunder Mifflin Employees by Ellelque*
14. Trivial Pursuits by Comfect
15. I just wanted to be famous. By Stablergirl
16. The Love Song of Squirrel McPants by time4moxie

*like last year, this is pretty much solely thanks to internet searches ;-)

2018 New and Updated stories with most hits

1. Wake Me Up by agian18
2. Terra Incognita by Comfect
3. Slow by agian18
4. Love Suffers Long by BringingTheJam
5. Sociology 101 by BigTuna
6. Restart by agian18
7. Crazy Night in Philly by miserycrush
8. Invincible Summer by shutterbug
9. Waiting In The Sun WishYouWould
10. the things that made us you and me by BigTuna
11. Anywhere But Here by NobleLandMermaid
12. This Thing Called Life by warrior4
13. Through the Glass by Rach3l
14. Paying Court by Comfect
15. More Than a Day, More Than a Word by NobleLandMermaid

Most Downloaded ePubs in 2017

• The Love Song of Squirrel McPants by time4moxie
• Away From the Cameras by girl7
• Tomorrow's Gonna Be a Brighter Day by Rach3l
• Only by girl7
• Wake Me Up by agian18
• Hey Jealousy by Hey Jealousy
• Climbing As We Fall by girl7
• What Happens Tomorrow by girl7
• Distance Learning by time4moxie
• In My Life, I Love You More by andtheivy
• Cardiac Care by Vampiric Blood
• A Blink of an Eye Deedldee
• Nearing the Edge by girl7
• In The Night by I Know This Much Is True
• I just wanted to be famous. By Stablergirl
• Breakdown by time4moxie
• Set Fire to the Rain by dedeen

Most Words Added

1. agian18 [249015]
2. Comfect [127321]
3. warrior4 [121027]
4. BigTuna [103331]
5. Coley [78637]
6. Rach3l [70981]
7. WishYouWould [63532]
8. NobleLandMermaid [51448]
9. miserycrush [37841]
10. Duchess Cupcake [26936]

Top Reviewers of 2018

1. Duchess Cupcake [259]
2. warrior4 [180]
3. Coley [171]
4. BigTuna [134]
5. Comfect [124]
6. BecauseOfYou [109]
7. Clover [99]
8. agian18 [80]
9. Merria [42]
10. alittlestitious2 [36]

Top Jellybean Givers of 2018

1. Clover [369]
2. Duchess Cupcake [347]
3. Comfect [341]
4. TheCelticOne [297]
5. warrior4 [160]
6. BecauseOfYou [123]
7. BigTuna [117]
8. MCapps [105]
9. Coley [90]
10. Dwangela [84]
11. agian18 [80]
12. NobleLandMermaid [76]
    

* 3198 jellybeans given total in 2018 Thanks everyone for making 2018 a great year, here's to making 2019 even better!


--Admin Team on January 08, 2019 03:07 pm 0 Comments

Thanks all the writers who submitted to our 2018 Halloween Writing Contest, now it's time to decide a winner!

We have eight entries which you can find here: Halloween Writing Contest 2018. They are listed in alphabetical order by title and you can easily move from one entry to the next by clicking on the links found at the bottom of every story. Please read all the entries before making your decision! Once you have decided on your favorite, please vote here.

Voting is open until Wednesday November 14th, 11:59pm Pacific Time

What to know before voting:

• Make sure you are registered on the archive, votes from non-members will not be counted
• Every member gets ONE vote, no double registering or using multiple accounts to cast multiple votes!
• If you are one the writers, you may vote but no voting for yourself. Your vote will be tossed if you do so.
• This is a secret ballot, the contest authors and other users won't see who voted for whom. We ask that you refrain from stating which entry you voted for publicly, such as in reviews or in the shoutbox, while voting is open.
  
• The Readers and Mods choices will be announced shortly after voting closes on Nov. 12th.
  

Some additional things:

* On the voting form, we ask you to match your favorite entries with it's key plot point. The 8 stories are all pretty unique so if you read the story, you should know which is which. Vote that don't match the story with the correct plot point won't count.

* The voting form has two optional fields for feedback, one regarding this contest and one asking about a potential Christmas event, and we would really like to hear your thoughts!

* The Mods' Choice will be determined by MTTs three mods, and the Readers Choice and Mods choice will be different entries.

* We will be in contact with the authors via email about the participation gift and the prizes for the 2 winners.

* Full contest rules and FAQs can be found here

* Any questions, concerns, comments can be directed to MTT.fanfic@gmail.com

Thank you and Happy Voting!

--Admin Team on November 04, 2018 01:25 pm 0 Comments

FunRaiser, emphasis on the FUN

This past July marked 12 years of MTT online, a feat that wouldn't be possible without the generosity of our members! Our annual FunRaiser is going on now to get the costs of the archive covered until next July, so if you have enjoyed MTT please consider contributing (we'll even send you a gift if you donate $10+)!

Full Details at our Blog

You get a Fic Rec, and you, and you!

As a lead up to our 12th birthday, we mods got together to bring you 31 days of fanfic recommendations. Covering a different topic every day, we made lists that hopefully went beyond the more popular stories and authors. We hope with these lists you get to discover some new favorites! Check it out at our blog:

MTT Presents: Month of Fic Recs

Month Digest Email

Whether you don't come around to the archive too often, or like getting handy lists delivered to your inbox, we invite you to sign up to our Monthly Fic Digest. On the first of every month, you will get an email with all the new and updated fics the previous month. You can sign up for this monthly digest (as well as other emails from MTT) on the Newsletter Sign-Up page

Challenges Challenge

Wanna write a story but stuck on ideas? That's what Challenges are good for! And if you answer one of the prompts we have specifically selected for the quarterly Challenges Challenge you will get a special banner on your story! Here are the new challenges for the 3rd quarter of 2018:

• Deleted Scenes: Write a story expanding on one of the many classic deleted scenes
• Mamas and the Papas: post a story centered on the Beeslys and/or the Halperts
• Spy Who Pranked Me: Write an AU where Jim is a secret agent and Pam gets caught up in the plot(or vice versa!)

What we're working on

At MTT we're always working to bring you a better site and new fun content. At the moment we are working on: a Jim and Pam info page (feel free to look at what we have so far here), a writing contest for the fall, new site themes, better Favorite options and more! We always value your feedback and hearing what you'd like to see at MTT so please feel free to contact us !

--Admin Team on August 09, 2018 02:55 pm 0 Comments

For the last year and a half or so we've been selecting an author of the month every month to showcase their stories. We have mostly focused on selecting authors who were less well-known and perhaps overlooked back in the day. However now that we are more active, we will be changing up who and how we select AOTMs. We are still going to follow the basic guideline of selecting authors with at least 5 stories, but we will now follow this basic pattern:

Month 1: a recently active author
Month 2: an all-time popular author
Month 3: a lesser known or over-looked author

and repeat! We also want readers input on who they think should be the next AOTm, which you can so via the contact form.

March JAM Madness

Just for fun we are running March JAM Madness at our instagram. We're pitting some of the top JAMtastic episodes against each other and seeing who earns the title of top JAMisode! Voting takes place via our story on instagram .

Newsletter Sign-up

Whether you are a member or not, you can sign up for our email newsletters ! You can also sign up for monthy fanfic digests to your inbox and for live chat reminders.

Challenges Challenge

There's still time take part in this quarter's challenges! We encourage you to write a Vegas story, a behind-the-scenes of Michael's movie Threat Level Midnight and many others! We also area always interesting in new ideas for challenges. Please click here for more info

And that about does it! Remember check out all these features and contact us with any problems or suggestions! 

--Admin Team on March 08, 2018 12:12 am 0 Comments

Happy Autumn everyone! This October, we are introducing a new feature: the Challenges Challenge!

How it works: Every 3 months we will introduce a handful of challenges, which are story prompts or themes. We'll have a combo of admin choices, an old challenge that went unanswered and maybe a Reader's challenge as well! Write a story for one of the challenges and your story will earn a little banner. But really this is just meant to be a way to keep writer's inspired and keep new stories coming! You can find more info and how to enter on this page: Challenges Challenge

Here are the challenges for Q4 2017:

• Bad Date (JAM style): Jim and Pam have a terrible first date (but he still buys a ring a week later)
• "Nice Morning, too" : What did Jim & Pam get up to that inspired the talking head at the start of S9E21 "Living The Dream" *wink wink*
• Life In Austin: Write a story about Pam and Jim's life in the Texas capital
• High School Reunion : write about any character's high school reunion

None of these getting your creative juices flowing? Send in your suggestions for challenges and we'll consider them for the next round!

--Admin Team on October 12, 2017 09:32 pm 0 Comments

If you can believe it, July 9th marks MTT's 11th birthday! An all new MTT admin team took over last year with the goal of bringing the site up to date, adding some new features and get activity going again. And with new themes, the Download ePub feature, our Valentine's day contest, new social media accounts, and the just-launched jellybean system, we think 2016-17 was a success!

Of course, today being our birthday also means that MTT's annual hosting bill is due this month. So if you would like to give us something, you can give the awesome gift of a contribution to the site! A contribution of $10+ will earn you a small JAM gift, but every dollar is sincerely appreciated! You can read the full details of our annual funraiser here. FUNRAISER EXTENDED THROUGH AUGUST!

If you can't give monetarily but still want to make a contribution, you can do so by submitting new stories, leaving reviews and jellybeans, following and liking our social media, interacting with fellow fans, making recommendation to friends, etc. Anything to keep MTT the great place for PB&J and Office fans that it is is your gift to us every day!

Now onto our next year!

--MTT Admin Team on July 09, 2017 08:35 pm 1 Comments

In our recent survey, many members expressed a desire for way to interact with each other beyond reviews and such. Though we had set up a community of sorts on the blog the consensus seemed to be it was cumbersome and difficult to navigate. We agree as so we're heading a back to basics and relauching the MTT forums. They have a more traditional forum look but should be easier to get around and highly mobile friendly!

Right now, registration is by invite only and we prefer if you already registered here on the archives. If you'd like to join please let us know through the contact form or in an email to MTT.fanfic@gmail.com.

If you are one of the couple dozen people who registered on the previous community you are already registered and your email/username and password for login should be the same!

If I'm registered on the archive, why do I have to register on the forum too?
They are two different software systems and sadly we don't have the technical know-how to link them. But you should be able to pick your name username and even same password if you'd like.

Come join us today!

--Admin Team on June 04, 2017 04:06 pm 0 Comments